This 2024 - Let's Win the Battle of Headlines

The real reason Palestinians do not have a free press

The past few days have again shown that the P.A. and Hamas are doing their utmost to silence and intimidate Palestinian journalists.

Hamas security forces guard a rally in Gaza City on March 30, 2022. Photo by Attia Muhammed/Flash90.
Hamas security forces guard a rally in Gaza City on March 30, 2022. Photo by Attia Muhammed/Flash90.
Bassam Tawil

It is no secret that the Palestinians do not have a free press. The media in the West Bank and Gaza Strip is controlled by the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, respectively. The P.A. and Hamas evidently want Palestinian journalists to serve as mouthpieces for their corrupt and undemocratic governments. They do not tolerate any form of criticism. Any Palestinian journalist who does not comply is beaten, arrested or fired. The P.A. and Hamas apparently want Palestinian journalists only to serve as foot soldiers.

This fierce crackdown on Palestinian journalists, however, is ignored by the mainstream media in the West. When Palestinian journalists are brutally attacked, where is the outrage of foreign journalists? Their outrage seems reserved only for stories that reflect negatively on Israel.

If the attacks on Palestinian journalists were being carried out by Israeli soldiers, The New York TimesThe Washington Post and CNN would have dispatched teams of investigative reporters and “experts” to report Israel’s “atrocities.”

That is what these three American media outlets did regarding the tragic case of Shireen Abu Akleh, an Arab Christian correspondent for the Qatari-owned, Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated Al-Jazeera TV station, who was killed while covering armed clashes between Israeli troops and Palestinian gunmen in the city of Jenin in the northern West Bank. All three media outlets were obsessed with the case of Abu Akleh because they were trying to implicate Israel, even though there was no conclusive evidence that she had been hit by an Israeli bullet.

While the case of Abu Akleh caught the attention of many Western media outlets, no one appears to care about the condition of Palestinian journalists living and working under the P.A. and Hamas. In addition to severe physical assaults, Palestinian journalists also have their cameras and mobile phones confiscated by security officers belonging to the P.A. and Hamas. Sometimes the cameras and phones are returned, sometimes not.

The P.A. and Hamas have been at each other’s throats ever since 2006, when Hamas won a Palestinian parliamentary election. In 2007, the rivalry between the two parties reached its peak when Hamas staged a violent coup against the P.A. and seized control of the entire Gaza Strip.

The P.A. and Hamas do have one thing in common: the fear of an independent and free media. That is why they are sending their security officers and thugs to arrest and beat up Palestinian journalists.

On August 3, a video posted on social media featured P.A. officers in plainclothes severely beating Palestinian journalist Nidal al-Natsheh and destroying his camera in the city of Hebron. His crime: he tried to report about a protest by university students against human rights violations committed by the P.A.

On Aug. 6, Palestinian journalist Ali al-Samoudi was injured when Palestinian security forces opened fire at a group of Palestinians in Jenin. Al-Samoudi was reporting on Palestinians who were celebrating a terror attack in Tel Aviv. The P.A. was apparently worried that scenes of Palestinians rejoicing over the murder of a Jew (a municipal patrolman killed in the attack) would expose the Palestinians’ glorification of terrorists and support for the murder of Jews.

Another journalist injured during the incident was Mohammed Abed. He reportedly sustained a direct hit from a tear gas canister fired by Palestinian security officers. The Palestinian Quds News website, where Abed works, condemned “recurring assaults and the intentional targeting of journalists” by the P.A.

On July 31, Palestinian Authority security officers arrested journalist Sami al-Sa’i at his workplace in the city of Tulkarm, also in the northern West Bank. Al-Sa’i has been arrested a number of times for allegedly criticizing the P.A. on social media. Because of his repeated incarcerations, he has been unable to find work in the local and foreign media. Recently, to support his family, he has been selling juice on the streets of Tulkarm.

On July 17, P.A. security forces arrested journalist Akil Awawdeh, also for critical posts on social media. Hours before his arrest, Awawdeh had ridiculed the Palestinian security forces’ spokesperson for stating the P.A. does not arrest people because of their political affiliation.

This past week, Hamas security officers attacked and detained several Palestinian journalists trying to report on widespread protests against Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

The Palestinian Journalists Syndicate (PJS) said the Hamas officers threatened the journalists and prevented them from covering the protests. It said that journalists Mohammed al-Baba and Bashar Taleb were taken to a Hamas police station where they had their cameras and mobile phones searched and confiscated. The PJS named a number of other journalists also detained and threatened by Hamas security forces and militiamen: Ehab Fasfous, Fouad Jaradah, Mohammed Abu Awn and Mohammed Haddad.

If Palestinians think that the Palestinian community, including their Western colleagues, care about their predicament, they are painfully mistaken. Many in the international community who pretend to be “pro-Palestinian” do not really care about the Palestinians at all, or about the too-many-to-count vicious human rights violations committed against them every day. They only care about one thing: bash Israel.

When the P.A. and Hamas beat and arrest Palestinian journalists, the United Nations and so-called human rights organizations look the other way. Western journalists covering the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Western universities are no better.

These journalists appear so obsessed with reporting on Israel’s “crimes” —real or imagined—that, presumably to avoid casting the Palestinians in a bad light, they painstakingly avoid any story that might reflect negatively on the P.A. or Hamas. By doing that, however, the international community and media are, in reality, doing endless harm to the Palestinian people, who are then forced to continue suffering, without a murmur of help from anyone, under the repressive and undemocratic regimes of the Palestinian Authority and Hamas.

Originally published by the Gatestone Institute.

The opinions and facts presented in this article are those of the author, and neither JNS nor its partners assume any responsibility for them.
You have read 3 articles this month.
Register to receive full access to JNS.

Just before you scroll on...

Israel is at war.

JNS is combating the stream of misinformation on Israel with real, honest and factual reporting. In order to deliver this in-depth, unbiased coverage of Israel and the Jewish world, we rely on readers like you.

The support you provide allows our journalists to deliver the truth, free from bias and hidden agendas. Can we count on your support?

Every contribution, big or small, helps remain a trusted source of news you can rely on.

Become a part of our mission by donating today
Thank you. You are a loyal JNS Reader.
You have read more than 10 articles this month.
Please register for full access to continue reading and post comments.
Never miss a thing
Get the best stories faster with JNS breaking news updates