An Israel supporter wrote to me recently asking why one of my recent articles focused only on “left-wing” anti-Semites and neglected “right-wing” anti-Semites.
The question itself reveals a painful conflict for many Jewish Democrats—as most American Jews are—who take offense when members of their party are accused of slandering Israel. Logically, they feel that if Democrats are criticized, then they are criticized.
It’s no surprise that American Jews embrace the Democrat Party and its traditional liberal values—support of civil liberties, protection of minorities (ethnic, sexual and racial), abortion and immigrant rights. Jews inherently sympathize with those who struggle against inequality, because we have suffered from centuries of bigotry and unequal treatment. It’s part of our DNA.
By the same token, most American Jews also wholeheartedly support Israel as the homeland and refuge of our beleaguered people. For decades, the Democratic Party made it easy for Jews to support their liberal values and Israel with no conflict. Indeed, for decades, Democrats in Congress and the White House have been among Israel’s most vocal and steadfast advocates.
Unfortunately, in recent years Democrats in high office have made this political calculus more challenging for Jewish Americans. Israel no longer enjoys unqualified support from the Democratic party. Indeed, many elected (and rank-and-file) Democrats express strong, even hateful opposition to the Jewish state.
For many American Jews, Israel is a peripheral issue. Among their political concerns Israel may rank fifth or sixth—or tenth—but not first. It’s fair to say that most Jewish Democrats are not going to vote for a Republican just because the Democrat candidate is hostile to Israel—assuming that candidate also supports racial justice, women’s rights and fighting climate change.
Yet of course it’s not necessary for Jewish Democrats to leave their party—or vote Republican—just because increasing numbers of Democrats are abandoning their loyalty to the Jewish state.
But if you’re a Democrat and you say you support Israel, you needn’t ask why pro-Israel advocates criticize leftist anti-Zionists who are Democrats. Unlike right-wing anti-Semites, it’s leftists whose influence is increasing in Congress, who control academia, entertainment and many mainstream media. But yes, of course, left or right, there’s no such thing as an acceptable anti-Semite.
Because if you support Israel, you oppose all who oppose Israel. You certainly don’t excuse them because they’re leftists or Democrats. You also don’t make excuses for them—such as saying that you, too, oppose Israel because you don’t like its duly elected prime minister.
If you’re a Jew who supports Israel because it’s the one and only homeland and refuge of our people, then you speak out against all who betray Israel’s interests, even those—especially those—within your party.
As a lifetime Democrat and passionate Zionist, I left my party when I realized the party had left me. During Barack Obama’s second term, I understood that despite Obama’s lip service to Israel—as well as much tangible support—the party had turned a corner.
This was painfully clear in the waning days of Obama’s tenure, when his administration orchestrated the notorious U.N. Security Council Resolution that condemned Israeli settlements “in the occupied Palestinian territories, including East Jerusalem,” and called them illegal under international law. U.S. Ambassador Samantha Powers then abstained from voting on the measure, failing to veto it and allowing it to pass.
Suffice it to say, the accusations in that resolution were lies. There are no “Palestinian territories.” There is no “East Jerusalem.” Israel’s communities in its ancient heartland of Judea and Samaria are simply, factually not illegal under international law.
Likewise, if you’re a Zionist, you support those who support Israel, regardless of party affiliation. This is clearly a bridge too far for many Jewish Democrats, who cannot stomach the thought of cheering the action of any Republican (especially if his name is Trump) on any issue—even if that politician clearly advances Israel’s interests. We see this syndrome no less among some Republicans, who will not praise a Democrat’s good deeds for Israel.
No one says that if you love Israel, you must leave the Democrat Party or vote for a Republican. But if you are a Jew who supports the existence of the one and only Jewish state—unfairly attacked as it is regularly by the United Nations, Arab armies, radical Islamists, woke intersectionality, and increasingly, Democrat members of Congress—you stand up, you protest. You roundly, loudly condemn them.
In other words, if you are a Jewish Democrat who believes in the legitimacy of the Jewish State of Israel—who believes its survival is critical to the survival of our people—you don’t play party politics. You take consistent, principled stands—irrespective of party.
That’s what Rep. Ted Deutch did several months ago when he called out fellow Rep. Rashida Tlaib for defaming Israel—a staunch U.S. ally—after Tlaib falsely accused Israel of being an “apartheid state.” As Deutch said, “When there’s no place on the map for one Jewish state, that’s anti-Semitism.” Would that Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi had the same fortitude in dealing with fellow Democrats in the “Squad.”
Because if you’re a Zionist—Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Hindu or atheist—Israel is bigger than the Democratic or Republican parties. It takes guts to stand up and chastise a politician in your own party at a town hall meeting or on the House floor when he or she is lying about Israel. But that is the price of protecting the Jewish people, and it’s the price of Israel’s future.
Ask yourself: Do you have the courage to do what Deutch did? Will you tell fellow Democrats—at a cocktail party or social-justice rally, over dinner or in your workplace—that something is rotten in your party because it fails to condemn Israel’s anti-Semitic enemies in its midst? Yet that kind of principled action, that kind of courage. is the true test of support for the Jewish people and our precious homeland.
James Sinkinson is president of Facts and Logic About the Middle East (FLAME), which publishes educational messages to correct lies and misperceptions about Israel and its relationship to the United States.
Be a part of our community
JNS serves as the central hub for a thriving community of readers who appreciate the invaluable context our coverage offers on Israel and their Jewish world.
Please join our community and help support our unique brand of Jewish journalism that makes sense.