This 2024 - Let's Win the Battle of Headlines

The Wire

Summer camps create a place for friendship or a breeding ground for hate

It is essential to support and promote initiatives that prioritize inclusivity, peace and coexistence—fostering a brighter future for all.

Camp Tel Yehudah on the Pennsylvania-New York border, the official national teen leadership camp of Young Judaea, is celebrating its 75th year in 2023. Credit: Camp Tel Yehudah.
Camp Tel Yehudah on the Pennsylvania-New York border, the official national teen leadership camp of Young Judaea, is celebrating its 75th year in 2023. Credit: Camp Tel Yehudah.

Summer camps worldwide offer a wonderful opportunity for children to build lifelong friendships and strengthen their cultural identity. American Jewish children and teens have a long history of spending their summers in sleepaway and day camps. In Israel, several charitable organizations sponsor camps that bring together Palestinian and Israeli youth to encourage a future generation that values understanding, empathy and peace—transcending barriers of conflict and fostering hope for a harmonious future.

U.S. Jewish Summer Camps

American Jewish kids have long flocked to summer camps in the mountains of Upstate New York, near the lakes and hills of the Midwest and in many popular outdoor settings across the country. There are also Jewish camps in other nations, including the first of its kind in Brazil for descendants of forcibly converted Jews. About 40% of American Jews attended a Jewish summer camp, a number far greater than those who attended a full-time Jewish school.

The history of Jewish summer camps pre-dated World War II. In the aftermath of the Holocaust, however, Jewish communal leaders saw camps as opportunities for cultural enrichment and fostering Jewish unity. The author of a book on American Jewish summer camps commented that “American Jews were incredibly anxious about the future of Jewish culture and Judaism as a religion.”

Flip Frisch attended Wisconsin’s Camp Herzl in the 1980s and “credits the camp with my entire Jewish identity. The whole reason I stuck with Judaism was camp and the connections I made.” Frisch returned to Camp Herzl as a camp counselor, later became a program director and today works at her synagogue.

Second Gentleman Doug Emhoff is planning to visit a Pennsylvania Jewish summer camp that he attended as a teen. He will be speaking to campers about Jewish life and anti-Jewish hatred. Emhoff is not the only adult returning to his roots. Many camps have alumni networks and reunions. Dozens of Camp Ramah alumni have been married since the 1950s. Young Judea’s Camp Tel Yehudah is celebrating its 75th anniversary this year.

Peace-Promoting Camps

Seeds of Peace is a U.S.-based summer camp that brings together kids and educators from both sides of conflicts. The peacebuilding charity was founded by an American Jew and originally focused on the Palestinian-Israeli peace process. The first summer camp in Maine in 1993 included 46 Israeli, Palestinian, Jordanian and American teens.

Haifa Staiti, a Palestinian from Jenin, described how it was hard “talking with Israelis I had up until now only thought of as enemies.” As a 14-year-old attending Seeds of Peace, she became friends with an Israeli; their friendship continues more than 20 years later. Canada’s Heart to Heart and MIT’s MEET are similar camp programs.

There also are organizations connecting Palestinian and Israeli youth in Israel with peers in the Palestinian territories. The Peres Center for Peace and Innovation is a leader in promoting coexistence. Through the Peres Center, founded by the former Israeli prime minister and president, young Palestinians and Israelis team up in the Twinned Peace Sports Schools program. Arabs and Jews play together on the same teams in soccer, basketball and other sports. One Voice and the Jerusalem Youth Chorus also bring Israelis and Palestinians together throughout the year to build common bonds.

Palestinian Summer Camps Promote Hate

In stark contrast, some leaders within Palestinian society who have a history of naming schools and sports stadiums memorializing terrorists have chosen summer camps as opportunities to undermine peace and promote violence. The Palestinian Authority operates summer camps in the West Bank. This year’s camps openly taught that a Palestinian state will replace Israel. Children were taught to paint maps of Palestine from the River Jordan to the Mediterranean Sea, reinforcing the often-heard chant: “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free.”

A record 650 P.A. camps are educating 65,000 West Bank Palestinian youth in 2023. A senior leader of the Palestinian Authority last year described the importance of these camps: “The goal of these camps is to serve as a melting pot and formulate the consciousness of these children according to the Palestinian national ideology.” He highlighted the “national action” undertaken by a terrorist who murdered 10 Israelis, honoring him as “deserving blessings” for his “milestone” sniper attack.

Iranian-backed Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad terrorists run their own camps in Gaza. They serve as a tool for indoctrinating the younger generation with radical ideologies and training them to become future operatives in their terrorist organizations. A PIJ leader explained to the campers that it is their responsibility to keep the “flame of jihad” until the “liberation of Palestine,” meaning the destruction of Israel.

Points to consider:

  1. Summer camps can promote positive or negative values.

Youth camps are usually intended to create a fun and upbeat environment where campers enjoy the outdoors, learn new sports and skills, and make lifelong friends. American Jewish summer camps create an opportunity where campers can connect with their heritage, traditions and values. Palestinian leaders, however, use summer camps to exploit impressionable young minds, promote extremist ideologies and glorify violence. Recognizing the impact of summer camps in shaping young minds, it is essential to support and promote initiatives that prioritize inclusivity, peace and coexistence—fostering a brighter future for all.

  1. Some summer camps promote peace between Palestinians and Israelis.

There also are organizations connecting Palestinian and Israeli youth in Israel with peers in the Palestinian territories to foster tolerance, coexistence and understanding. Seeds of Peace, founded by an American Jew, is a U.S.-based summer camp that bridges kids and educators on opposite sides of conflict. The Peres Center, established by former Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres, teams up young Palestinians and Israelis in the Twinned Peace Sports Schools program. In one program, Arabs and Jews play together on mixed soccer teams and finish the year with a World Cup-themed tournament. There are other examples of summer camps that reach across divides and nurture peaceful relations.

  1. The Palestinian education system nurtures systemic hate and violence.

Palestinian children, like children everywhere, are not born to hate. Influential Palestinian leaders and politicians propagate inflammatory rhetoric and use Palestinian schools, summer camps, TV networks and mosques to spread inciteful propaganda. U.N.-run schools employ teachers who incite violence, creating an indoctrination system that teaches incitement to terrorism against Israelis and Jews. Palestinian Authority textbooks promote jihad and reject Israel’s right to exist. The Palestinian Authority, Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad run summer camps that extend the hateful themes taught in their classrooms. This incitement is then passed down from one generation to another through education and socialization. The perpetuation of this messaging makes it challenging to foster meaningful dialogue and pushes Palestinian-Israeli peace further away.

Read more here

You have read 3 articles this month.
Register to receive full access to JNS.
About & contact The Publisher
The Focus Project is a consensus initiative of major American Jewish organizations that provides crucial news, talking points and background content about issues affecting Israel and the Jewish people, including antisemitism, anti-Zionism and relevant events in the Middle East. Click here to receive weekly Talking Points from The Focus Project.
Releases published on the JNS Wire are communicated and paid for by third parties. Jewish News Syndicate, and any of its distribution partners, take zero responsibility for the accuracy of any content published in any press release. All the statements, opinions, figures in text or multimedia including photos or videos included in each release are presented solely by the sponsoring organization, and in no way reflect the views or recommendation of Jewish News Syndicate or any of its partners. If you believe any of the content in a release published on JNS Wire is offensive or abusive, please report a release.
Comments
Thank you. You are a loyal JNS Reader.
You have read more than 10 articles this month.
Please register for full access to continue reading and post comments.
Never miss a thing
Get the best stories faster with JNS breaking news updates