Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Court halts order requiring Penn to provide employee data in federal Jew-hatred probe

“Penn does not have a strong chance of prevailing on appeal but makes, narrowly, a showing of irreparable harm,” U.S. District Judge Gerald J. Pappert wrote in his ruling.

Benjamin Franklin Statue at University of Pennsylvania
Benjamin Franklin Statue at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. Credit: Adam Jones, Ph.D. via Wikimedia Commons.

A federal judge on Monday granted the University of Pennsylvania’s request to pause enforcement of an order requiring it to turn over information about Jewish staff to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission as it pursues an appeal.

U.S. District Judge Gerald J. Pappert ruled that the court’s March 31 order compelling compliance with an EEOC subpoena is “stayed until the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issues its decision and mandate in Penn’s appeal,” according to court filings.

The subpoena seeks names and contact information for employees who may have witnessed or experienced alleged antisemitic harassment, part of an EEOC investigation into claims that the university “subjected Jewish employees to a hostile work environment based on religion.”

In granting the stay, Pappert wrote that “Penn does not have a strong chance of prevailing on appeal but makes, narrowly, a showing of irreparable harm,” adding that a pause would not substantially harm the EEOC investigation and would allow for an “orderly” review of the university’s appeal.

The decision temporarily relieves Penn of a requirement to comply with most of the subpoena by May 1.

“The teachers we have, we don’t respect and support in the way that they deserve,” Paul Bernstein told JNS. “If we’re successful and we grow enrollment, that problem only gets bigger.”
“The message being sent is that you can get away with attacking someone in broad daylight because you disagree with their opinions, especially if it involves feelings about Israel,” Joshua Burt, of the Anti-Defamation League, told JNS.
“Not identifying Hamas as a terrorist organization is, I think, a failure, Marc Miller told the Canadian Press. “And not clearly stating that, for example, Hamas intended to kill Jews is, I think, an unfortunate error in curation and should be rectified.”
“This is life for Jews under the leadership of Mayor Zohran Mamdani,” advocacy group StopAntisemitism wrote.
The Committee to Protect Journalists said Nika Soon-Shiong’s five-year board term expired as it reviews whether Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad operatives were misclassified as journalists killed in Gaza.
“Blaming Israel for the rise in antisemitism on the political left and in the Democratic Party specifically is classic narcissistic behavior,” Jim Walsh, chair of the state’s Republican Party, told JNS. “It’s what abusive husbands do to battered wives.”