Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Harvard Palestinian alumni group calls on dean to resign for vetoing anti-Israel former head of HRW

Letter claims veto demonstrates Dean Douglas Elmendorf’s “hostility to academic freedom and honest human rights discourse.”

Harvard University
Entrance gate and east facade of Sever Hall at Harvard University in Cambridge, Mass. Credit: Roman Babakin/Shutterstock.

The Harvard Kennedy School’s Palestinian Alumni Collective demanded that the school’s Dean Douglas Elmendorf resign after he blocked the appointment of former Human Rights Watch (HRW) Executive Director Kenneth Roth as a senior fellow.

The Carr Center for Public Policy’s offer to Roth was rescinded by Elmendorf, who accused him of anti-Israel bias, according to the far-left magazine The Nation.

The letter called Elmendorf’s decision “profoundly wrong” and “demonstrates his hostility to academic freedom and honest human rights discourse.”

“Dean Elmendorf has abrogated his responsibility to the HKS community and the principles underpinning free thought in a free society,” the letter asserted. “As the body representing Palestinian alumni of HKS, we call for HKS Dean Douglas Elmendorf’s resignation.”

The authors claimed they have collective experiences with “institutionalized anti-Palestinian discrimination” at the school, citing “the administration’s support for Israeli state-sponsored violence and apartheid.”

They also accused Elmendorf of hosting Israeli officials who “bear responsibility for war crimes perpetrated against Palestinians, including the crime of apartheid, a crime against humanity.”

In addition to Elmendorf’s resignation, the letter demands the reinstatement of Roth’s fellowship.

The group welcomed the “invaluable contributions” of human rights activists, “progressive Jewish civil society leaders” and other supporters of their cause.

“We hope that HKS can become a more welcoming institution for Palestinians and those who stand with us in our struggle for freedom from occupation and colonization,” the letter concluded. “We look forward to the day when defending our rights and freedom is a cause for recognition and commendation rather than sanction.”

“We’ll show up strong, with pride and solidarity, and keep the focus on peaceful support,” Yehuda Sichel, who owns Huda in downtown Philadelphia, told JNS.
“The reason we lost is the war,” the U.S. vice president wrote. “If you’d like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next six years was worth it, then do so” but “that’s at least honest.”
European Jewish leaders welcome the institution as Germany’s president warns against making Jewish protection a political bargaining chip.
Voice of the People begins selecting its second cohort after concluding its inaugural cycle with 20 initiatives and a Budapest conference.