Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

London police slammed for detaining man with Jewish pendant

The Met claim he was arrested for getting too close to anti-Israel protesters, and not because of the symbol.

Jewish Star, Magen David
A Star of David. Photo by Cottonbro Studio/Pexels.

Police in London on Aug. 29 detained a Jewish man whom officers accused of “antagonizing” anti-Israel protesters, allegedly by wearing a Star of David pendant, a British paper reported on Saturday.

Police interview footage obtained by The Telegraph shows an officer accusing the Jewish man, who was not named in the article, of openly wearing a Star of David that could cause “offense.” The police told the paper that the man had been arrested for getting “too close” to the protesters and not because of his pendant.

The man was handcuffed and detained by police for almost 10 hours, the Telegraph reported. He told the paper that his detainment appeared to be an attempt by the Metropolitan Police to “criminalize the wearing of a Star of David.”

The symbol measured 2 cm.—less than an inch—across, according to the paper. The man, who does not wish to be named out of fear for his safety, remains on police bail more than six weeks after his arrest while police continue their inquiries, according to the paper.

Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar wrote on X on Saturday: “The Star of David is a symbol of Jewish identity, not provocation. The fact that Jews are warned in central London not to display it publicly shows how rampant antisemitism spread through hateful ‘pro-Palestinian’ marches in Britain has poisoned the streets.”

Sa’ar added, “This is a moral disgrace. The British authorities must act: ban antisemitic slogans and conduct a full institutional review.”

The protest was held outside the Israeli embassy in Kensington in central London. The man, a lawyer in his 40s, insisted that he was acting as an independent legal observer, monitoring the event for unlawful behavior by the protesters and to scrutinize the actions of police.

But officers instead accused him of “antagonizing” the crowd and being part of a counter-protest.

He was held for questioning at Hammersmith police station, before being released at 4:30 the next morning.

The Metropolitan Police told the Telegraph that the man had been held not due to the Star of David, but for allegedly “repeatedly breaching” an order to keep opposing protest groups apart.

Police claim he got “very close” to the pro-Palestine protesters on multiple occasions, and alleged his actions went “beyond observing to provoking,” leading officers to designate him as “actively participating as a protester,” therefore subjecting him to conditions of the Public Order Act.

The man is a founder of the Society of Independent Legal Observers (Silo), set up earlier this year to monitor the growing wave of anti-Israel protests.

Gary Mond, chairman of the National Jewish Assembly (NJA), a Jewish community group, told JNS: “The detainment of a man wearing a Star of David sends a truly frightening message, not just to Britain’s Jews but also its Christians.”

A symbol displaying a belief in God “is now deemed intolerable because it might offend others with different beliefs or none at all,” Mond said. “This shows how our government and our woke left-wing culture deride, trample on and ultimately wish to extinguish Jews and Jewish life in Britain. And G-d fearing Christians will be next.”

Last year, Gideon Falter, who heads the U.K.-based Campaign Against Antisemitism, was prevented by a policeman from crossing a street as an anti-Israel protest passed.

“This is a pro-Palestinian march. I am not accusing you of anything, but I am worried about the reaction to your presence,” the officer told him in a video Falter’s group posted to X on April 18, 2024.

“The Metropolitan Police have made a series of high-profile errors in their responses to these demonstrations,” the Board of Deputies of British Jews said in response to that incident.

Canaan Lidor is an award-winning journalist and news correspondent at JNS. A former fighter and counterintelligence analyst in the IDF, he has over a decade of field experience covering world events, including several conflicts and terrorist attacks, as a Europe correspondent based in the Netherlands. Canaan now lives in his native Haifa, Israel, with his wife and two children.
“The Iranian regime executed a 19-year-old for demanding democracy,” stated Sen. John Fetterman. “I stand with his memory and the thousands of other young Iranians.”
More than 70,000 Americans have returned to the United States from the Middle East since the Iran conflict began on Feb. 28.
“If this thing is growing, this inauthentic account is going to deceive more people,” Rep. Chris Smith told JNS. “Especially overseas, where there’s a language barrier or something.”
“We are now part of a process at the International Court of Justice initiated by Nicaragua,” Berlin said. “We have decided to focus on this process.”
“No more weapons to support an illegal war,” Sanders wrote on Thursday, setting up a vote that will largely gauge Democratic support for Israel.
“We are deeply grateful for speaker Julie Menin’s leadership, her presence and for standing up against antisemitism when it truly matters,” David Greenfield, CEO of the Met Council, told JNS.