Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Trump nominee for State withdraws after Senate grilling on comments about Jews, race

Jeremy Carl announced his decision to withdraw from consideration to be assistant secretary of state for international organizations after senators scrutinized his past comments about “white genocide” and the Holocaust.

State Department
The Harry S. Truman Building of the U.S. State Department in Washington, D.C., July 2, 2025. Credit: Isaac D. Pacheco/U.S. State Department.

The Trump administration’s nominee to oversee the United Nations and other multilateral bodies at the U.S. State Department withdrew from consideration on Tuesday after senators grilled him last month over past comments about Jews, Israel and race.

Jeremy Carl, a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute, said that his nomination was no longer viable as he lacked unanimous support from Republicans on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

“Unfortunately, at this time, this unanimous support was not forthcoming,” Carl wrote. “I accept that political reality and do not wish to have the president, Secretary Rubio or the rest of his team waste valuable time and energy attempting to change that decision.”

In January, Trump nominated Carl to be assistant secretary of state for international organizations, a role that supervises U.S. policy regarding the United Nations and its subsidiaries.

At his nomination hearing in February, Carl floundered under intense questioning about his record of incendiary comments and said he regretted his comments downplaying the significance of the Holocaust.

“Sometimes, I take an idea too far, and I made some comments in interviews about minimizing the effect of the Holocaust that were absolutely wrong,” he said.

Carl, who was born Jewish but converted to Christianity, also faced questions about his claims that there is a “genocide” against white people underway in the United States, and that America spends too much “time and energy” on Israel.

His positions on Israel, in particular, seem to have cost him the support of Sen. John Curtis (R-Utah), who said after the hearing that he would not vote for Carl.

“People shouldn’t think that, ‘Oh this is not going to happen to me,’” the 32-year-old Judaic studies teacher told JNS. “It can happen to anyone walking the streets, anyone with their groceries.”
The state must make changes “to clearly address content that is not permitted, while preserving the ability of candidates to present their qualifications to voters,” its secretary of state told JNS.
Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote that the New Jersey attorney general’s demand for donor information may deter donors from associating with First Choice, a Christian pregnancy resource center.
“It’s very important, not only for Israel, but also for the United States, that people will be more familiar with the real history,” Yigal Dilmoni, of American Friends of Judea and Samaria, told JNS.
“When influential voices spread conspiracy theories, promote terrorism or dehumanize Jewish people, it fuels real-world violence and intimidation,” Rep. Josh Gottheimer said.
The authority “continues to provide a system of compensation in support of terrorism through new mechanisms and under a different name,” the U.S. State Department informed Congress.