Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Woman indicted with hate crime for anti-Semitic attack on New York City subway

The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office was originally “very resistant” to prosecute the charges as a hate crime, but following public outrage, classified her actions as such.

A New York City subway train. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
A New York City subway train. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A woman who went on an anti-Semitic tirade against two Jewish people on a New York City subway in December was indicted with a hate crime by a Manhattan grand jury, attorneys of one victim told Fox News on Wednesday.

Israeli college student Lihi Aharon and an Orthodox Jewish man she sat next to on the subway faced a “disturbing” anti-Semitic attack by Zarinah Ali, a 38-year-old African-American who also physically attacked Aharon. Police arrested Ali that night and charged her with assault.

The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office was originally “very resistant” to prosecute the charges as a hate crime, but following public outrage, classified her actions as such, Aharon’s lawyer Kenneth Belkin told Fox News.

“I still bear the physical and emotional scars from my attack, and I expect they will be with me for many years to come. Today, at least I can feel satisfied that my attacker will be held responsible for her actions, and I hope that my experience may help bring this type of hatred to light,” Aharon said in a statement.

Belkin and The Lawfare Project provided Aharon pro bono representation.

“Just because one minority is persecuting another minority doesn’t mean it is not a hate crime,” said Brooke Goldstein, attorney and executive director of The Lawfare Project.

The Nassau County Police Department told JNS that Bruce Blakeman released a statement about a fire at the Young Israel of West Hempstead, but instead of providing that, a Blakeman rep asked JNS to name the police spokesman.
“They get social credit within their political bases in terms of talking about settler violence and and taking up the side of the Palestinians on issues between them and Israel,” Rafael Mangual of the Manhattan Institute told JNS.
The U.S. envoy also said antisemitism “didn’t exist” during his upbringing and warned of an unintended clash between Israel and Turkey.
“There is not, and there will not be, a Palestinian state,” the Israeli prime minister pledged. He also called for the corruption trial against him to be dropped.