Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Melbourne sees renewed anti-Israel protest as fires rage across Victoria state

Organizers defy requests from police and mayor to postpone the event.

Pro-Palestinian Rally in Melbourne, Australia
A pro-Palestinian rally in Melbourne, Australia, on Oct. 15, 2023. Photo by Matt Hrkac via Wikimedia Commons.

A couple of thousand pro-Palestinian activists rallied against Israel in Melbourne on Sunday, defying police’s and local authorities’ requests to cancel their event due to raging bushfires in the Australian summer.

The anti-Israel protest came less than a month after the Bondi Beach attack at a Chanukah event in Sydney, and as hundreds of Iranian protesters were being killed by security forces of the Islamic Republic on the streets of Iran.

Sunday’s event, in which attendees slammed the government’s invitation for Israeli President Isaac Herzog to visit Australia, included chants such as ‘From the river to the sea’ and ‘Long live the intifada,” went ahead despite a request by Melbourne Mayor Nick Reece and the police to nix the event due to the fires raging throughout Victoria state.

“We can close a city—300,000 of us closed the [Sydney Harbour] Bridge,” Nasser Mashni, president of the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network, said at the rally, the first since Dec. 14’s Bondi Beach terrorist attack. “We can shut down a city, a bridge, a town, wherever it might be, because we are the people.”

A Victorian government spokesperson had said that no one should protest this weekend.

“If you are going to come into the city to whip up hate and division, you will be dealt with by police,” a spokesperson told the Herald Sun.

Victoria Police Deputy Commissioner Bob Hill previously stated that “now is not the right time for protests” due to the force being busy with the wildfires.

“Common sense and respect for other people in need should mean any planned protest does not go ahead. ... With Australia’s Jewish community still hurting after the tragedy at Bondi, and Victoria fighting catastrophic fires, to proceed with these protests would be selfish, divisive and offensive,” he said.

Jeremy Leibler, president of the Zionist Federation of Australia, told JNS Sunday, “On the same day Victorians are fighting bushfires and the world is watching Iranians risk their lives against a brutal regime, these activists chose another rally. It’s becoming harder to pretend this is about helping Palestinians and not about demonizing Israel and keeping Jewish Australians on edge.”

“The decision by Free Palestine Melbourne to proceed with today’s protest, despite explicit requests from Victoria Police and the Lord Mayor during a serious bushfire emergency, reflects gross insensitivity and a troubling disregard for public safety and civic responsibility,” Colin Rubenstein, executive director of the Australia/Israel and Jewish Affairs Council (AIJAC), said in a statement sent to JNS.

“At a time when emergency services are stretched protecting lives and property, deliberately diverting police resources for a political demonstration is both irresponsible and deeply concerning,” he continued.

“If these protestors truly cared about human rights, they would instead be rallying in solidarity with the brave Iranian men and women, who are risking their lives to demand basic dignity and rights from the clutches of the Islamic regime,” Rubenstein said.

Etgar Lefkovits, an award-winning international journalist, is an Israel correspondent and a feature news writer for JNS. A native of Chicago, he has two decades of experience in journalism, having served as Jerusalem correspondent in one of the world’s most demanding positions. He is currently based in Tel Aviv.
Fire damaged more than 30 structures, destroyed 15 homes and 10 businesses, and forced the evacuation of some 100 families.
Jerusalem began cracking down on the Health Work Committees group following its involvement in the murder of 17-year-old Israeli teenager Rina Shnerb in 2019.
“I think we need to invest in Israel’s Arab society—in education, employment and infrastructure. If we don’t, we’ll be the ones who suffer,” the lawmaker told JNS.
Bar-Ilan University researchers reported that pregnant women living near more vegetation had lower levels of long-term stress hormones.
With the principal blocs separated by a handful of seats in most polls, the campaign could be decided less by movement between Netanyahu’s Likud and Eisenkot’s Yashar than by which smaller parties survive the 3.25% electoral threshold.