Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Trump: Fewer than 24 hostages remain alive

“Two months ago, we were pretty sure” U.S.-Israeli Hamas captive Edan was alive. But Hamas “toughened up” things. the American president said.

Trump National Day of Prayer
U.S. President Donald Trump speaks during a National Day of Prayer event in the Rose Garden of the White House, May 1, 2025. Photo by Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images.

U.S. President Donald Trump said on Thursday that he recently learned that fewer than 24 hostages remain alive in Hamas captivity.

“Out of 59, you had 24 that were living, and now I understand that it’s not even that number,” Trump commented regarding the figures that Israeli authorities have publicly shared in recent months.

The president spoke during a National Day of Prayer event at the White House attended by the parents of U.S.-Israeli Hamas captive Edan Alexander.

“Edan Alexander’s parents are here today. He is the last known living American hostage,” Trump said. “We don’t know how he’s doing, really. We think we know, and hopefully positive,” he added.

“Two months ago, we were pretty sure. It looked like he was getting out. But they’ve [Hamas] toughened up a little bit. And it’s a terrible thing, I know, what you’re going through,” Trump told Yael and Adi Alexander.

On Monday, Sara Netanyahu, the wife of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, interrupted him when the premier said there are “up to 24 alive.”

“To date, we have returned 196 of our hostages, 147 alive,” Netanyahu said during an event honoring Israelis and Diaspora Jews picked to light torches at the main state Independence Day ceremony.

“There are up to 24 alive,” Netanyahu continued his remarks, followed by a brief pause and his wife whispering, “fewer,” into his ear.

Sara Netanyahu’s response was based on classified information that was relayed to Cabinet ministers, the Kan News public broadcaster reported.

Speaking at the annual International Bible Contest in Jerusalem on Thursday, Independence Day, Benjamin Netanyahu reiterated that there are “up to 24 living, 59 in total. We want to bring back the living and the deceased as well.

“It’s a very important goal,” the prime minister continued, while adding, “In the war, there is the ultimate goal, and that ultimate goal is the victory over our enemies, and that we will achieve.”

Jerusalem’s three goals for the war in the Gaza Strip are to eradicate Hamas as a military and political body, bring all of the hostages home, and prevent the enclave from re-emerging as a security threat to Israel in the future.

With Lt. Gov. Sara Rodriguez suspending her campaign, state Rep. Francesca Hong, a Democratic Socialists of America member with a record of anti-Israel activism, and former Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes have emerged as the Democratic Party’s leading candidates ahead of the Aug. 11 primary.
Rep. Jake Auchincloss accused President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu of breaking the compact underlying U.S. military assistance to Israel by launching the war against Iran.
“I want to maintain the dialogue and the conversation, because I think they need to work harder to try to figure out how to get more friends instead of creating more enemies,” the Washington Democrat said.
“The rules that they’ve been using to build these data centers were not intended for these kinds of data centers,” David Greenfield, of Met Council, told JNS. “Now they’re happening very frequently, and they’re having unintended consequences.”
She helped turn JINSA into the “very significant face of the American Jewish community to the US military,” the JNS publisher said.
The 15 still appear on the AIPAC website in a section about candidates it supports, but users are no longer offered links with which to donate to the candidates.