Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Added hate crime charge against anti-Israel protester, Toronto police says

Muhammad Anas Sial now also faces a count of ‘wilful promotion of hatred” in connection with an incident in mid-March.

Toronto Police Car
Credit: Toronto Police Service.

The Toronto Police Service’s hate crime unit said on Saturday that Muhammad Anas Sial, 33, of Toronto, now faces a charge of “wilful promotion of hatred” in addition to that of “public incitement of hatred,” with which he was charged earlier in the year.

Sial is accused of being part of what the police department described as a “group of pro-Palestinian protestors,” which marched on March 15 “across Bathurst Street towards a group of pro-Israeli protestors.”

On April 2, the police department said that Sial allegedly brought “several hate propaganda signs to the protest,” approached pro-Israel demonstrators and “shouted inappropriate comments” and carried a “hate propaganda sign.”

That day, the department’s hate crime unit executed a search warrant at Sial’s home and a storage locker, and Sial was located and arrested, the department stated. It said on April 2 that it applied to the office of the attorney general to bring the charge of “wilful promotion of hatred.”

The latter charge was added on May 20, the department said on Saturday.

If a defendant is convicted of hate crime charges, the “judge will take into consideration hate as an aggravating factor when imposing a sentence,” the department said.

“Willful promotion of hatred and advocating genocide are hate propaganda (hate speech) offences which require the attorney general’s consent to lay charges,” the department said. “These charges are often laid at a later time.”

See more from JNS Staff
“In this political environment, he may be as reliable a supporter as possible that the Democratic caucus would sign off on for the position,” political science scholar Dan Schnur told JNS.
“Anyone who attempts to pose a threat or attack Israel will face devastating consequences,” said Danny Danon, Israeli ambassador to the global body.
“I think they’re much more susceptible to being targeted if a public official wants to target them, if a community wants to target them,” Rep. Josh Gottheimer told JNS.
“For the love of God, if Israel is not capable of creating an investigation committee, then I think it is suitable and appropriate that the good people of the United States, the people in Congress, do provide us the answers that we’re looking for,” Ruby Chen said.