Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Homeless man pleads guilty to synagogue fire in Duluth

“I lit a little fire and woke up, and it was a lot bigger,” Matthew James Amiot testified in front of the State District Court, adding that he unsuccessfully attempted to put out the blaze.

The remains of the Adas Israel Congregation in Duluth, Minn. Source: Screenshot.
The remains of the Adas Israel Congregation in Duluth, Minn. Source: Screenshot.

A homeless man pleaded guilty on Tuesday to accidentally setting fire to a historic synagogue in Duluth, Minn., on Sept. 9 that destroyed the building.

Matthew James Amiot, 36, confessed that he tried to stay warm when he lit a small fire that spread out of control and affected the 118-year-old Adas Israel Congregation.

“I lit a little fire and woke up, and it was a lot bigger,” he testified in front of the State District Court, adding that he unsuccessfully attempted to put out the blaze, which caused a firefighter to be hospitalized.

Accelerants were not detected at the scene, and authorities have said there is “no reason to believe that this is a bias or hate crime.”

Matthew James Amiot
Matthew James Amiot

Amiot is scheduled to be released from custody with supervision on Wednesday.

Sentencing is slated for Oct. 25.

He faces up to three years behind bars and/or a $5,000 fine on the felony charge of starting a negligent fire resulting in more than $2,500 in damages, in addition to a misdemeanor charge of starting a negligent fire resulting in bodily harm.

There was relief in some circles that the fire was not arson, and that the synagogue itself was not targeted as part of an intentional crime.

Judy Schwank told JNS that “if we can get it through both bodies and get it to the governor’s desk, he will sign it.”
“I am constantly making pistols, tanks and Kalashnikovs out of paper and cardboard,” the boy wrote to his father.
The reversal “sends an unfortunate signal at a time of rising antisemitism and sustained efforts to isolate Israel economically,” Evan R. Bernstein, CEO of B’nai B’rith International, told JNS.
The Combat Antisemitism Movement condemned the disruption, calling claims that Israel commits genocide and kills children a modern blood libel.