Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Last-ditch efforts may salvage plan for mixed prayer at Western Wall

Ministers vote by phone late Sunday night on new members for Ministerial Committee on Holy Places, with aim of creating an egalitarian prayer space at the holy site • Energy Minister Yuval Steinitz replaces Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked on the committee.

Priestly Blessing during Sukkot
Jews pack the area in front of Jerusalem’s Western Wall for the Birkat Kohanim Priestly Blessing during Sukkot, Oct. 8, 2017. Photo by Yaakov Lederman/Flash90.

The saga surrounding the proposed establishment of an egalitarian prayer space at the Western Wall took another turn as ministers voted by phone late Sunday night on a new panel for the Ministerial Committee on Holy Places.

Loath to address the political hot potato, Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked resigned from the committee earlier in the day. Shaked’s departure followed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s removal of Culture and Sport Minister Miri Regev from the committee last week over her refusal to support his plan for an expanded plaza for non-Orthodox and nontraditional prayer.

Netanyahu on Sunday criticized the ministers who have refused to support his move to create the egalitarian prayer space, saying, “I’ll handle this.”

The Knesset must now approve the ministerial committee’s new members in a vote scheduled for Monday. Only then can the new panel give the green light to continue building the prayer space at the Western Wall.

Netanyahu, meanwhile, has assumed Miri Regev’s role as head of the ministerial committee, while Energy Minister Yuval Steinitz agreed to fill the vacuum created by Shaked’s resignation from the committee.

The Ministerial Committee on Holy Places is tasked with facilitating a planned expansion ‎of the mixed-gender prayer plaza at the Western Wall for non-Orthodox worshippers to be located several dozen yards from the familiar plaza.

Shaked and Regev had recently come under pressure by opponents of the plan, who include haredi and religious Zionist rabbis, as well as some archaeologists, whose objection is rooted in considerations of historic preservation.

“Approval of the plan is a necessary step,” said the prime minister. “An agreement has been in place for 20 years. Now it is being settled. The justice minister said she can’t vote [in favor of the egalitarian expansion]. I’m prepared to take the responsibility. I understand that Gila [Social Equality Minister Gila Gamliel] is prepared. Anyone willing to join will be most welcome.”

Officials close to Netanyahu stressed that if the expansion plan isn’t approved, the High Court of Justice will force the state to allow non-Orthodox worshippers to pray according to their own traditions at the main Western Wall plaza; hence, the plan’s detractors have an interest in allowing it.

According to the agreement between Netanyahu and Regev, after the construction plan is approved the culture and sports minister will return to chair the Ministerial Committee on Holy Places.

Ariel Kahana is a seasoned Israeli journalist and diplomatic correspondent, frequently sought after as a TV commentator and speaker. He began his media career as an editor and presenter for Arutz 7 radio and has since held key roles across print, broadcast, and digital platforms. Over the years, his work has provided him with a front-row seat to many of Israel’s most pivotal events.
“Israel cannot survive without the Diaspora’s support, and the Diaspora needs Israel for its identity and a safe haven in a time of need,” Israel Bachar, Israeli consul general to the Pacific Southwest, told JNS.
The resignation of Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick could clear the path for Elijah Manley, a convert to Judaism running as a Democratic Socialist and frequent Israel critic.
The president said he is maintaining a blockade on the Strait of Hormuz and extending the ceasefire until the “fractured” government of Iran can submit a proposal.
“It is deeply concerning that Catholic University selectively applies equal-time policies,” the president of school’s Students Supporting Israel chapter said.
“Infertility has a heightened impact on the Jewish community, as many Ashkenazi Jews are carriers of genetic diseases that can be fatal,” the organizations wrote.
“The Iranian regime must be held accountable for its extortion of global energy markets and indiscriminate targeting of civilians with missiles and drones,” the U.S. treasury secretary stated.