Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Sierra Club bows to anti-Israel activists and cancels trips to Israel

Complaints said the organization was engaging in “greenwashing,” ignoring the Palestinians and instead focusing on the Jewish state’s environmental values and practice.

View of salt formations on the Dead Sea shore, July 7, 2020. Photo by Mila Aviv/Flash90.
View of salt formations on the Dead Sea shore, July 7, 2020. Photo by Mila Aviv/Flash90.

Over the years, the environmental group Sierra Club has noted Israel’s green endeavors, such as its use of electric buses in 2016 and its desire to build a tunnel in Haifa using green initiatives. It has even taken people on environmental trips to Israel, including one called “Wings Over Israel: Birding, Nature and Culture.”

But after coming under pressure from anti-Israel groups, the California-based environmental NGO Sierra Club canceled its scheduled trips to Israel, according to a report in the J. The Jewish News of Northern California. Anti-Israel activists claimed that the organization was engaging in “greenwashing,” giving Israel “legitimacy” by ignoring the Palestinians and focusing on the Jewish state’s environmental values and practice.

The paper quoted an email from Mary Owens, chair of the Sierra Club’s National Outings division. In it, she said the group had received a letter on Jan. 20 from a “Jewish American activist” urging them to cancel planned trips to Israel in March.

When told they do not “restrict trips due to regional conflicts or politics,” the activist was not happy and said he would get others involved in his efforts to get Israel trips canceled.

Additional letters soon arrived from other “activist organizations” threatening to expose the Sierra Club for failing to respect its new organizational values.

The Sierra Club has recently included a commitment to social justice and anti-racism. After meeting with representatives from the “progressive” groups, the Sierra Club decided to cancel the Israel trips, according to the J.

“Despite the attacks on our coverage from opposing directions on a near-daily basis, we will not let critics or advocacy campaigns deter us from such independent reporting,” a spokesman for the paper told JNS.
“These are not just numbers on a page but are lived experience of all Jewish Americans,” Rep. Brad Knott said, of Jew-hatred, on the House floor.
“Abe believed that hearts could change,” said Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove, of Park Avenue Synagogue.
“The accused was identified as a result of tips received from the public,” police said.
It comes as the Israeli Foreign Ministry claimed that the paper published a “shameful attack” on the Jewish state before the release of a report on sexual violence on Oct. 7.