Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

With no clear alternatives, Israel maintains status quo in Gaza

“Israel finds itself trapped, without any significant change in sight,” said Yoram Meital, professor of Middle East Studies at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev

A view of the Gaza Strip as seen from the Israeli side of the border on Aug. 9, 2018. Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.
A view of the Gaza Strip as seen from the Israeli side of the border on Aug. 9, 2018. Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.

Despite ongoing attacks emanating from the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip, Israel recently re-extended the Gaza fishing zone to 10 nautical miles and allowed Qatar to deliver $20 million in cash for humanitarian assistance to Gaza’s 2 million residents.

Israel’s policy towards Gaza has been to maintain the status quo—something that has upset many of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s supporters and even has some opposition politicians to the left voicing support for a more forceful response.

According to Yoram Meital, professor of Middle East Studies at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, an argument can be made that maintaining the status quo, while not ideal, is the best option open to Israel at the moment.

“The position of the Israeli government in recent years is based on the premise that the continuation of the status quo vis-à-vis the Palestinian parties in general and in the Gaza Strip in particular serves the Israeli interest better than the other two alternatives,” Meital told JNS.

Asked what he thinks about an alternative policy, Meital said Israel’s current approach “is better than launching a wide-ranging military operation which forces Israel to retake responsibility in Gaza Strip with its 1.8 million population,” in which case he noted that Israel would likely face “ongoing guerrilla warfare.”

Additionally, said Meital, retaking the Strip “will dismiss the claim that Israel has withdrawn from Gaza and is not responsible for what is happening there.”

“A third possibility is the renewal of the political process, but Israel’s position is that that is not realistic,” he said. “Thus, Israel finds itself trapped in Gaza, with any significant change not in sight.”

The continued Hamas-led riots on the Gaza-Israel border, along with repeated rocket and incendiary balloon attacks from the Gaza Strip, are making life increasingly difficult for residents of Israel’s south.

Explore Ariel Ben Solomon’s analytical pieces on Middle East politics, Israel, and international relations at JNS.org.

Belgrade condemns the U.N. official’s remarks on its military ties with Israel, calling them beyond her mandate.
Tel Aviv underground community finds resilience beneath the Dizengoff Center
Aaron Kaplowitz, president of the U.S.-Israel Business Alliance, told JNS that state elected officials should “publicly say that California is open for business to Israeli entrepreneurs.”
The progressive Michigan lawmaker said she plans to introduce a House resolution “standing with the people of Lebanon.”
The Maricopa County supervisor has “been an outspoken supporter of the Jewish community and felt it was important to ensure the candidate he nominated was aligned with this core belief,” a spokesman told JNS.
“If you grab too much, you don’t grab anything at all,” the former U.S. envoy on Jew-hatred said, quoting the Talmud.