Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Polish appellate court throws out ruling against two Holocaust scholars

It comes days after Poland passed a new law that sets a 30-year limit on restitution claims for property stolen by the Nazis during World War II, which has led to a row between Israel and Poland.

The Polish flag with Warsaw in the background. Credit: Velishchuk Yevhen/Shutterstock.
The Polish flag with Warsaw in the background. Credit: Velishchuk Yevhen/Shutterstock.

A Polish appellate court threw out a February ruling against two Holocaust scholars that said they needed to retract their research, claiming it defamed a Polish man by saying he was complicit in the murder of Jews during the Holocaust.

The appellate court ruling comes days after Poland passed a new law that sets a 30-year limit on restitution claims for property stolen by the Nazis during World War II and then seized by the Communist regime, which has led to a row between Israel and Poland.

In a joint statement on Monday, the co-authors of Night Without End: The Fate of Jews in Selected Counties of Occupied Poland Jan Grabowski and Barbara Engelking said: “We greet the verdict with great joy and satisfaction all the more that this decision has a direct impact on all Polish scholars, and especially, on historians of the Holocaust.”

The Warsaw District Court had previously ruled that Grabowski, a professor of history at the University of Ottawa in Canada, and Engelking, director of the Research Centre for the Extermination of Jews, had to issue a retraction of their work and apologize to the niece of Edward Malinowski, who was briefly mentioned in their book as being complicit in the murdering Jews during the Holocaust.

Many feared that ruling would limit research on the role of Poles during the Holocaust.

According to The Associated Press, Malinowski’s niece plans to appeal the decision to the Polish supreme court.

“Such hate has no place in our schools or our state, especially as we begin Jewish American Heritage Month,” said Maryland Gov. Wes Moore.
“While our ability to provide additional information at this time is limited, we will continue to keep the community informed,” the private D.C. university stated.
“This is not a prank. It was an act of intimidation meant to spread fear,” Vince Gasparro, a Liberal parliamentarian, told JNS.
“We welcomed this traitor into our nation with open arms,” the U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan said. “And he repaid us by building a bomb and helping our great enemy.”
The “failed approach” to lasting peace between the countries has “allowed terrorist groups to entrench and enrich themselves, undermine the authority of the Lebanese state and endanger Israel’s northern border,” said State Department spokesman Tommy Pigott.
“One has to wonder how that humble pie tastes for the Democrats today,” Sam Markstein of the Republican Jewish Coalition told JNS.