Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Netanyahu rescinds nomination of former Navy chief as Shin Bet head

Coalition pushback and U.S. objections derailed the appointment of Eli Sharvit as the director of the Israel Security Agency.

Eli Sharvit
Portrait of former naval chief vice-admiral (res.) Eli Sharvit at his home in central Israel, Jan. 19, 2024. Credit: Israel Hadari/Flash90.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has reversed his decision to appoint Vice Adm. (res.) Eli Sharvit as the new director of the Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet), less than 24 hours after announcing the nomination.

Netanyahu thanked Sharvit for his readiness to take on the role but stated he would be considering additional candidates before making a final decision, according to a Tuesday morning statement from the Prime Minister’s Office.

The nomination of Sharvit, who previously served as commander of the Israeli Navy, prompted pushback from members of Netanyahu’s political bloc. Critics pointed to Sharvit’s alleged involvement in demonstrations against the government’s 2023 judicial reform initiatives and public remarks criticizing climate policies endorsed by U.S. President Donald Trump during his first term.

U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham expressed strong disapproval of Sharvit’s potential leadership, labeling the appointment as highly concerning due to Sharvit’s past statements regarding Trump.

This leadership shake-up comes amid Netanyahu’s attempt to replace the current Shin Bet chief, Ronen Bar, whose dismissal was temporarily blocked by an injunction issued by Israel’s Supreme Court.

Joshua Marks is a news editor on the Jerusalem desk at JNS.org, where he covers Jewish affairs, the Middle East and global news.
“Just like we knocked them out again today, we’ll knock them out a lot harder and a lot more violently in the future if they don’t get their deal signed, fast,” President Donald Trump said.
“This is meant to make the job of the police and prosecutors easier,” Tara Cook-Littman, of the Jewish Federation Association of Connecticut, told JNS.
“No challenges were received during the public display period,” Shirley N. Weber’s office told JNS.
A 25-foot buffer zone around houses of worship would include a penalty for protesters who breach it, though the state Assembly speaker said nothing has been agreed to yet.
“An event at a city-owned pool that was publicly and indiscriminately advertised as ‘whites only’ would surely violate the Constitution,” the executive director of the state Public Safety Office wrote. “The same must be true here.”
The gift from the Jan Koum Family Foundation is expected to triple the size of the Jerusalem hospital.