Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Israeli justice minister moves to override court to deport illegal African migrants

“The bill is nothing more than election campaigning,” said Tel Aviv councilwoman Suzy Cohen Zemach. “There’s already a peace treaty in Eritrea, but no one is sending the migrants home.”

Sheffi Paz with other residents at a protest march in south Tel Aviv against African illegal aliens, June 2, 2018. Photo by Miriam Alster/Flash90.
Sheffi Paz with other residents at a protest march in south Tel Aviv against African illegal aliens, June 2, 2018. Photo by Miriam Alster/Flash90.

The Ministerial Committee for Legislation will meet next week to discuss a bill that would give the government the authority to circumvent the High Court of Justice and deport illegal migrants.

The proposed legislation, which would give the Knesset the power to vote down High Court rulings with a special majority, was submitted by Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked and MK Shuli Mualem-Rafaeli (both of Habayit Hayehudi).

“The override clause will restore the proper balance between the three branches of government,” Shaked said on Tuesday.

“The Kulanu Party [led by Finance Minister Moshe Kahlon] has committed to supporting an override clause as long as it is restricted to the issue of illegal migrants.

“I hope that the members [of Kulanu] will fulfill their promise to the residents of south Tel Aviv,” she said, referring to the impoverished area where many illegal African migrants reside and where clashes have occurred with local residents.

Israeli activists from South Tel Aviv expressed skepticism over the initiative.

“The bill is nothing more than election campaigning,” said Tel Aviv city councilwoman Suzy Cohen Zemach. “There’s already a peace treaty in Eritrea, but no one is sending the migrants home. Shaked, like the rest of the ministers from Habayit Hayehudi, is abandoning the residents of South Tel Aviv and constantly putting off a solution to the problem.”

Israel currently hosts some 35,000 African migrants, mainly from war-torn Sudan and dictatorial Eritrea.

Tens of thousands of Africans began arriving in Israel in 2005 through Egypt after Egyptian forces violently quashed a refugee demonstration, and word spread of safety and job opportunities in Israel. The refugees had often endured perilous journeys before crossing the Egypt-Israel border.

Israel completed a barrier in 2012 that stemmed the influx, and since then has wrestled with the challenges posed by those migrants already in the country. Many hold menial jobs in hotels and restaurants, and thousands settled in South Tel Aviv neighborhoods.

Neighbors have complained about crowding and crime as a result.

The Foreign Workers Law, also known as the “deposit law,” was implemented a year ago and allows the government to withhold 20 percent of migrants’ monthly paychecks, to be returned only if they voluntarily leave the country.

Migrants and the NGOs that support them say the law is yet another attempt by an anti-migrant government to force them out.

In August, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu instructed National Security Adviser Meir Ben-Shabat to re-examine the issue of deporting illegal African labor migrants back to their home countries.

The directive follows a ruling by the Justice Ministry’s Appeals Tribunal stating that with Eritrea planning to cancel its mandatory draft, it would allow the state to send Eritreans illegally in Israel back home.

“I want to see long-term peace. I want to see a two-state solution,” the Democratic congresswoman said as her progressive challenger accused pro-Israel groups of influencing her campaign.
“I think that the Israeli defense industry especially is very resilient, and I think they know how to adapt to the new situation,” Col. (Res.) Aviram Hasson told JNS.
“We are also committed to impacting elections beyond the House, and Senate races are expensive,” Patrick Dorton, spokesman for United Democracy Project, told JNS.
The New York City Police Department told JNS that it is still determining motive but is probing the incident as bias related.
“Israel will do everything in our power to disarm Hamas,” Danny Danon said during a U.N. Security Council debate. “The question is, when will you?”
Han Tran, whose term on the Washington State Human Rights Commission expired at the end of June, wrote that “antisemitism was being instrumentalized to justify the slaughter of Palestinians.”