Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

3,000 warn Scotland leader his Israel stance fuels Jew-hatred

Activists say that First Minister John Swinney’s arms boycott and “genocide” rhetoric endanger Jews.

First Minister of Scotland John Swinney at his office in Edinburgh, May 10, 2024. Credit: The Government of Scotland.
First Minister of Scotland John Swinney at his office in Edinburgh, May 10, 2024. Credit: The Government of Scotland.

Activists against antisemitism in Scotland delivered a letter to the head of the government on Sunday, signed by nearly 3,000 people, warning that his anti-Israel actions and rhetoric were fanning the flames of Jew-hatred.

The letter delivered to Scottish First Minister John Swinney followed his announcement on Thursday that his government would pause new awards of public contracts to arms companies supplying Israel.

“Not one Palestinian life will be saved by these measures, but Jewish life in Scotland will be put further at risk,” Leah Benoz, founder and director of Scotland Against Antisemitism, said in a statement about the letter that her organization authored and got nearly 3,000 people to sign.

The letter noted that, in announcing the boycott, Swinney said that “in the face of genocide, there can be no business as usual.” Israel and the U.S. have roundly rejected the characterization of Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza as genocide.

Scotland’s government “will pause new awards of public money to arms companies whose products or services are provided to countries where there is plausible evidence of genocide being committed by that country—that will include Israel,” Swinney said.

He also called for the recognition of a Palestinian state—something the British government has said it will do next week if Israel does not meet certain conditions, including reaching a ceasefire.

In the letter, the signatories asked Swinney to “retract inflammatory language, particularly around ‘genocide,’ engage with the Jewish community in Scotland,” and “commit to concrete measures to protect Jewish safety.”

The signatories also wrote that although Scottish Jews number around 5,000 people, or 0.093% of the population, they were the victims of approximately 17% of all religiously motivated hate crimes last year.

Canaan Lidor is an experienced journalist and international correspondent for JNS, covering Europe, Australia and global Jewish affairs.
It’s “absurd and tragic that there are U.N. experts who are supposed to care about the rights of women, especially to combat sexual violence, and she’s one of the world’s major deniers of sexual violence against Israeli women,” Hillel Neuer told JNS.
“We’re going to keep pushing, and we’ll get there,” Rabbi Josh Joseph told JNS. “We’ll get to the $1 billion that we need.”
“We don’t need it. We need to teach real, honest history,” Sonja Shaw, school board president of Chino Valley Unified School District, told JNS.
The Israeli ambassador accused Vanessa Frazier, the U.N. special representative for children and armed conflict, of amplifying antisemitic content and unverified claims about Israel, and called for a review of her continued suitability for office.
A federal judge found that efforts to remove Hassan Suleiman Khalaf to Gaza or an Arab village in Judea and Samaria via Israel remain viable.
Speaking to local authority leaders, the Israeli premier said bold military decisions changed the regional balance of power and averted existential threats.
Benny Gantz, JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan S. Tobin, Gilad Erdan, Mosab Hassan Yousef, Nissim Black and leading voices in security, diplomacy, media, law and Jewish communal affairs headline the summit’s third day in Jerusalem.