Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Shin Bet chief admits agency failed to predict Hamas attack

“As the one who is at the head of the organization, the responsibility for this is on me,” said director of Israel’s Security Agency Ronen Bar.

Shin Bet head Ronen Bar speaks at the annual Cyber Week conference at Tel Aviv University on June 27, 2023. Photo by Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90.
Shin Bet head Ronen Bar speaks at the annual Cyber Week conference at Tel Aviv University on June 27, 2023. Photo by Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90.

Ronen Bar, director of the Israel Security Agency, or Shin Bet, took responsibility on Monday for his part in failing to provide adequate warning for Hamas’s surprise attack on Oct. 7.

In the letter Bar sent on Sunday night to Shin Bet employees and their families, he wrote: “Despite a series of actions we carried out, unfortunately, on Saturday we were unable to generate sufficient warning that would allow us to foil the attack.

“As the one who is at the head of the organization—the responsibility for this is on me. There will be time for investigations—now we are fighting,” he added.

Bar said that Shin Bet forces displayed “courage and fighting spirit” as they immediately engaged the enemy without hesitation. “We lost 10 of our best men; many of us were wounded,” he wrote.

He said the agency had set up a special department, together with the Israel Defense Forces, to recover abductees and missing persons.

“We are in a war, not a round. A round is won with a picture of victory and in silence. A war is ended by conquering and changing the situation. There is no border limit. There is no time limit. Until the end,” Bar wrote.

On Thursday, IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi also gave a public mea culpa, admitting that the army failed to protect Israel’s citizens and properly guard the border fence with the Gaza Strip in a speech to reporters on Thursday.

The failure of Israel’s security establishment enabled hundreds of terrorists to stream through the fence on Oct. 7 and wreak havoc in Israeli communities in the western Negev, killing at last count more than 1,400 people, mostly civilians, and wounding thousands more.

To date, more than 150 hostages are being held by Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

Aoun’s historic D.C. visit comes amid U.S.-brokered talks to disarm Hezbollah and pilot the replacement of Israeli forces in Lebanon with Lebanese troops.
Acclaimed Israeli photographer Ziv Koren and poet Noam Horev combine images, film, music and artifacts in an immersive tribute to Israel’s pain and resilience after the Hamas attacks.
Nationalist figures tell JNS that the upcoming ballot represents a broader struggle between conservative and progressive values.
Danny Danon accused the NYC mayor of engaging in “dark, antisemitic rhetoric,” promoting Hamas terrorists and wanting to meet with Iranian regime officials.
Sharren Haskel, recently resigned deputy Israeli minister of foreign affairs, told JNS that the Jewish state had offered the congressman full coordination, briefings, tours and security arrangements for his visit, “all of which he declined and didn’t even bother to reply to.”
More than 30 Israeli experts are aiding the earthquake-stricken country’s shift to long-term recovery.