Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Mamdani Jew-hatred plan ‘disingenuous political maneuver,’ Rabbinical Council president says

Rabbi Etan Tokayer told JNS that security grants and educational programs are welcome, but the New York City mayor must first address rhetoric from his own office.

Mamdani
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamadani at a security briefing ahead of United Nations General Assembly on Sept. 17, 2026. Credit: Kara McCurdy/Mayoral Photography Office.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s newly unveiled strategy to combat Jew-hatred is a “brazen and disingenuous political maneuver” that fails to address the mayor’s own rhetoric, according to Rabbi Etan Tokayer, Rabbinical Council of America president and rabbi of the Kingsway Jewish Center, a Modern Orthodox synagogue in Brooklyn.

“The absurdity of the arsonist offering to help douse the fire he helped set is maddening for anyone who harbors the most rudimentary respect for truth,” he told JNS.

The new strategy that Mamdani unveiled on Sept. 29 doesn’t mention anti-Zionism and has drawn criticism from Jewish leaders.

Tokayer told JNS that the strategy has some good things in it.

“Security grants and educational programs are always welcome; however, were Mayor Mamdani at all serious about combating antisemitism, he would begin by changing the rhetoric from his own office,” he told JNS, “first and foremost by stopping to promote the vicious genocide lie.”

“We urge the mayor to shift gears immediately before the consequences of his words lead to more serious violence against Jewish New Yorkers,” he said.

Rebecca Szlechter is a reporter at JNS based in New York City.
Judy Schwank told JNS that “if we can get it through both bodies and get it to the governor’s desk, he will sign it.”
The reversal “sends an unfortunate signal at a time of rising antisemitism and sustained efforts to isolate Israel economically,” Evan R. Bernstein, CEO of B’nai B’rith International, told JNS.
Israel’s foreign minister called it a historic day for ties between the two countries and an important day for the capital.
The Combat Antisemitism Movement condemned the disruption, calling claims that Israel commits genocide and kills children a modern blood libel.