Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Thousands of Jews march past Palestinian villages to Homesh

Right-wing Knesset members joined Israelis from across the country in a march to the settlement evacuated in 2005.

Participants in a march to the Homesh Yeshiva on April 19, 2022. Photo by Mael Benoliel.

During the Passover holiday, Israeli families traditionally go on tiyulim—treks in parks, nature reserves and to see various landmarks.

For thousands, Tuesday’s trek was quite unique. On short notice, a steady stream of visitors marched along an 11-kilometer route past Palestinian Arab villages to the Samaria hilltop of Homesh, a Jewish settlement that has repeatedly been dismantled, and where a lone makeshift yeshivah—a tent, really—remains precariously standing, under threat of government destruction.

“The thousands that are coming to Homesh want to tell the government to keep [its] hands off Homesh. We’ve had enough of the forced evacuations and the roadblocks. All of Israel is reinforcing the pioneers that are there. We are here to send a message that the public supports Homesh and the public expects Homesh to be rebuilt,” Yossi Dagan, head of the Samaria Regional Council, told JNS.

Organizers had attempted to put together the event for weeks, but the Israel Defense Forces—claiming a reduced ability to keep marchers safe due to other security concerns around the country, and concerned that the march could spark further tensions—initially refused to offer its protection. The army told organizers that they would be putting lives in danger by marching unguarded for long stretches through Palestinian Arab areas on their way to Homesh.

The IDF and organizers reached an agreement only on Monday. The military sealed off the roads to several Palestinian villages in the area. The event was initially supposed to draw thousands, and organizers claimed that upwards of 20,000 people attended.

Clashes between Israeli security forces and Palestinian Arabs erupted in Burka, near Shechem, with Arabs hurling stones and setting garbage on fire. Israeli forces responded with tear gas and rubber bullets. The Palestinian Red Crescent said that 79 Arabs in Burqa were treated, including 25 for tear-gas inhalation.

Palestinians clash with Israeli security forces in Burqa during a protest against a march of Israelis to Homesh, April 19, 2022. Photo by Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90.
Palestinians clash with Israeli security forces in Burqa during a protest against a march of Israelis to Homesh, April 19, 2022. Photo by Nasser Ishtayeh/Flash90.

‘We are neither settlers nor extremists’

Meanwhile, several hard-right Knesset members participated in the march, including Otzma Yehudit Party leader Itamar Ben-Gvir and Religious Zionist Party chair Bezalel Smotrich. Idit Silman of Yamina, the former coalition whip who left the government recently over concerns regarding its Jewish identity, leaving the coalition without a parliamentary majority, was also in attendance.

“Here, there’s a continuation of the Zionist enterprise. Look at the many people coming here, by foot and by car. And, thank God, even the army understood and permitted this to happen. We demand to return here and to reestablish a settlement,” Smotrich told JNS.

The march took on a festive atmosphere at the hilltop yeshivah, with singing and flag-waving. A Passover sermon from inside the tent was pumped through loudspeakers. The overwhelming majority of those attending appeared to be from Israel’s religious nationalist movement.

The families of terror victims Yehuda Dimentman and Shuli Har-Melekh also attended. Har-Melekh was a Homesh resident killed by Palestinians in 2003 in a drive-by shooting near Ramallah. Dimentman was a Homesh yeshivah student killed when a Palestinian terrorist opened fire at a convoy ferrying students back from the yeshiva. That attack fueled renewed calls to resurrect the Samarian settlements dismantled by the government in 2005 in conjunction with the Gaza disengagement. Israelis are barred from returning to the grounds of Homesh and the other Samarian settlements, but the yeshivah there has continued to operate for the past 15 years, even as adjoining rebuilt structures continue to be torn down by Israeli forces.

The family of terror victim Yehuda Dimentman give a press conference during the Shiva in Mevaseret Zion on Dec. 19, 2021. Photo by Yonatan Sindel /Flash90.
The family of terror victim Yehuda Dimentman give a press conference during the Shiva in Mevaseret Zion on Dec. 19, 2021. Photo by Yonatan Sindel /Flash90.

Ettya Dimentman, Yehuda’s widow, said on Tuesday: “The land of Israel belongs to the people of Israel. We are neither settlers nor extremists. We are just coming home. All the soldiers who fell [over] all the years in the wars, what did they fall for? They fell because they reclaimed the land of Israel. Today everyone is coming here on foot, freely, but tomorrow morning there will be a checkpoint here again, and if there is a checkpoint here again then this government is saying that this country does not belong to us.”

Silman, who seemed to receive an extra warm welcome from fellow MKs and attendees, told JNS, “It’s exciting to be here. I arrived at the invitation of Ettya, who wrote me that whoever lives by the teachings of the Torah must not give up their truth. I want to tell all teachers and rabbis and parents that there is something greater, and our faith lies with God.”

Mike Wagenheim is a Washington-based correspondent for JNS, primarily covering the U.S. State Department and Congress. He is the senior U.S. correspondent at the Israel-based i24NEWS TV network.
Limor Son Har-Melech, who introduced the bill and whose husband was murdered in a 2003 terror attack, stated that the “historic law” means “whoever chooses to murder Jews because they are Jews forfeits their right to live.”
Either Iran “agrees to abide by international law, or a coalition of nations from around the world and the region will make sure that it’s open,” the U.S. secretary of state said.
Lawyers for the council said that Queens councilmember Vickie Paladino sought the subpoenas “with the sole purpose of creating a public spectacle.”
It appears as “a living educational framework—a connection between Jewish communities in Israel and abroad, and a reflection of the strength of these communities across generations.”
“It becomes comfort, continuity and a way to feel connected to tradition and to one another at home,” Talia Sabag, of the Manischewitz parent company Kayko, told JNS.
The mayor said the NYPD informed him of the alleged firebombing plot against Within Our Lifetime co-founder Nerdeen Kiswani a day after a New Jersey man was charged for the threat.