Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Democracy on trial: Is Australia sliding away from free speech? (MK Simcha Rothman)

“Basic Law” with Aylana Meisel and guest MK Simcha Rothman, Ep. 23

In this episode of “Basic Law,” host Aylana Meisel, executive director at the Israel Law and Liberty Forum, sits down with special guests Robert Gregory, head of the Australian Jewish Association, and Knesset member Simcha Rothman to unpack Australia’s shocking visa bans against mainstream Israeli political figures.

For decades, Australia was considered one of the West’s strongest liberal democracies. Yet today, it is making headlines for denying entry to Israelis with right-wing political views, including former minister Ayelet Shaked, tech advisor and influencer Hillel Fuld and now Rothman.

The latest move comes amid rising antisemitism in Australia, including firebombed synagogues, as well as violent protests and the government’s push to sanction Israeli leaders like National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich while preparing to recognize a Palestinian state.

This episode explores the deeper implications:

  • What does Australia’s ban really say about free speech, Zionism and Western values?

  • How are these decisions tied to Australia’s foreign policy and its push for a two-state solution?

  • Why does the government apply hate speech laws selectively, targeting Jewish and Israeli voices while allowing radical Islamist and far-left figures to speak freely?

  • What does this mean for the future of Israel-Australia relations and for Jewish communities facing growing hostility?

With firsthand insights from Rothman and analysis from Gregory, the conversation exposes the contradictions at the heart of Australia’s policy, and the dangerous precedent it sets for democracies worldwide.

See more at: @JNS_TV. And don’t forget to hit the subscribe button!

The Israel Law & Liberty Forum is proud to partner with JNS to offer a platform for conservative and classical liberal legal thought from within Israel. Any opinions stated are those of the speaker and not meant to represent the positions of the forum or JNS. The forum is an organization that fosters thoughtful conversation and debate on key issues in Israeli law and democracy. The forum takes no official position regarding any specific policy issue, nor does it advance specific policies.

Aylana Meisel is the founder and executive director of the Israeli Law and Liberty Forum at the Herut Center. Aylana hosts the show “Basic Law” on JNS TV. Her opinions are her own and do not represent the Israel Law and Liberty Forum, which adopts no positions on policy.
“It doesn’t matter whether it’s Shia or Sunni. They’re all cut from the same cloth,” the deputy assistant to the U.S. president told JNS. “They all derive their ideological DNA from the Muslim Brotherhood.”
“Jewish New Yorkers deserve to mourn in peace, free from hatred and intimidation,” stated New York Gov. Kathy Hochul. “There is no excuse for this. None.”
“Mamdani could not even give us one day to mourn without defaming the Jewish people and giving cover to our enemies,” Inna Vernikov, a Jewish member of the New York City Council, told JNS. “We will not let Mamdani and his radical pals rewrite Oct. 7.”
“The charging by the FBI of Haverford College associate professor Guangtian Ha for harassment and intimidation of a Jewish Israeli professor closes the dotted line between verbal acts of harassment and actionable violence which, when Jews are the recipients, is far too often ignored,” Lori Lowenthal Marcus of the Deborah Project told JNS.