Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Tree of Life shooting defendant must undergo psychiatric evaluation

The prosecution has prevailed in its efforts to counter the defense’ mental-health claims.

Tree of Life Or L'Simcha Synagogue Crowd Pittsburgh
People pay their respects at a memorial in front of the Tree of Life Synagogue in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh to the 11 Jewish victims of a mass shooting a week earlier, Nov. 4, 2018. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

As juror selection continues into the third week of the Tree of Life*Or L’Simcha Synagogue mass-shooting trial in Pittsburgh, prosecutors of Robert Bowers will have the opportunity to rebut the defendant’s attorney’s anticipated claims of mental disorder.

While this debate has taken months, U.S. District Judge Robert Colville ruled on May 8 that the prosecution now could conduct a mental-health evaluation on Bowers with their own experts. The review of the lone gunman’s alleged psychological conditions will take place over four-and-a-half days with a maximum of six hours a day.

Colville wrote that “government mental health experts shall be permitted to examine the defendant as necessary and probative to rebut or confirm defense experts’ anticipated mental-health testimony.”

The defense claims that Bowers has schizophrenia, epilepsy and “structural and function impairments of the brain.”

Eleven Jewish worshippers, most of them elderly, were shot and killed in October 2018 during Shabbat-morning services in the deadliest U.S. antisemitic attack on record.

“We’re a tiny percentage of the population, yet we’re over 50% of the attacks, and the mayor’s diatribes don’t help,” Rabbi Allen Schwartz, of Ohab Zedek, a synagogue that the victim attends, told JNS on the fast of Tisha B’Av.
“You know that’s the other Jewish guy named Josh, right?” the New Jersey congressman wrote, after Rep. Summer Lee appeared to confuse him with Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro.
“Whether operating under the guise of charities, businesses or underground financial networks, those who enable Hamas will be exposed, sanctioned and held accountable,” the U.S. treasury secretary stated.
The United Nations agency “teaches Palestinian children to hate Jews, essentially functioning as a child soldier factory,” stated Rep. Chris Smith, who introduced the legislation.
“This reward offer is part of a broader effort to solicit information leading to the disruption of the financial mechanisms” of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the State Department said.
“The university has been able to protect its employees’ rights and none of the subpoenaed personal contact information was disclosed,” a University of Pennsylvania spokesman told JNS.