Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

‘BBC’ requests guest ‘critical of Netanyahu,’ Gaza ground offensive

The spokeswoman for the Israeli Embassy in the UK said there’s “nothing impartial” about wanting “someone who fits the predetermined narrative.”

BBC
The “BBC” logo on the side of The Forum building in Norwich, Norfolk, in the United Kingdom, on Dec. 18, 2019. Credit: Sebastiandoe5 via Wikimedia Commons.

The BBC recently explicitly asked to interview Israeli military personnel who are “critical of Netanyahu” and Israel’s recent ground offensive against the Hamas terror group in the Gaza Strip, according to Orly Goldschmidt, spokeswoman for the Israeli Embassy in the United Kingdom.

She posted a screenshot of the message, accompanied by a caption condemning it.

“Today, my team received this remarkable message from a BBC producer,” Goldschmidt wrote. “They don’t want to interview someone knowledgeable, nor someone relevant, just someone who fits the predetermined narrative. There is nothing balanced or impartial about this.”

The message, which was sent via WhatsApp, stated the BBC presenter wished to interview an “Israeli military voice” that was “critical of Netanyahu and the ground offensive.” They cited examples of what the criticism could be, including “concern about remaining hostages, stretching IDF capacity, destruction of Gaza or any other reason.”

The screenshot blurred the names of the BBC producer, presenter and intended recipient.

“This explains why the BBC and several other major networks won’t have me on anymore,” wrote Jonathan Conricus, senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and a former spokesperson for the Israeli Defense Forces. “I’m not willing to trash Israeli decisions or do my dirty laundry to feed their hatred of Israel.”

“This is absolutely disgraceful,” wrote Aviva Klompas, former director of speechwriting at the Israeli Mission to the United Nations. “BBC World refuses to host impartial guests, choosing instead to platform only those who will echo their political narrative.”

Eylon Levy, the former spokesman for the State of Israel, had just one word for this exchange. “Wow.”

The U.S. president issued the warning as he prepared to attend the dignified transfer of four U.S. service members recently killed in the conflict with Iran.
“I think one of the bedrocks of our city is protest,” the New York City mayor said when asked what Palestinian New Yorkers should do when the Israeli prime minister visits New York in September.
Gloria Romero, who is running for lieutenant governor of California, told JNS that after Oct. 7, anti-Israel demonstrations at UCLA cemented her party switch.
“As a Jewish leader and longtime resident of the state of Washington, it’s appalling that the state would permit that sort of incitement to violence against American Jews masquerading as political speech in a state publication,” Robert Spitzer of B’nai B’rith told JNS.
“Anyone who calls the State of Israel an apartheid state has no right to set foot in the State of Israel,” one justice said.
It would be the seventh round of direct dialogue between the two countries, following meetings held in the Italian capital last week.