Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Italy’s Meloni stunned by accusation of ‘complicity in genocide’ in Gaza war

“I don’t believe there is another case like this in the world or in history,” Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said.

Giorgia Meloni
Newly elected Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Orlando, Fla., on Feb. 26, 2022. Source: Vox España via Wikimedia Commons.

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said Tuesday that she and two Cabinet members were reported to the International Criminal Court for alleged “complicity in genocide” tied to Israel’s offensive against Hamas in Gaza.

“I don’t believe there is another case like this in the world or in history,” Meloni told state television RAI, expressing amazement at the accusation given that “Italy has not authorized new … arms supplies to Israel after Oct. 7.” (Italy blocked all new arms deals with the Jewish state weeks after the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack.)

Defense Minister Guido Crosetto and Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani were also denounced to the ICC, Meloni said, adding that she thought Roberto Cingolani, CEO of Italian defense firm Leonardo S.p.A., had also been named.

Cingolani, in a Sept. 30 interview with Italian daily Corriere della Sera, called the accusations of complicity “an unacceptable stretch,” noting it was based on the fact that Leonardo helped build F-35 stealth strike fighters for countries around the world, some of which were sold to Israel.

Cingolani said Leonardo’s workers were the target of a “completely unfair media campaign.” However, he also criticized Israel’s “disproportionate” response to Oct. 7.

The ICC told JNS that “any individual or group from anywhere in the world” may provide information to the ICC prosecutor about alleged crimes.

While the Court said it couldn’t provide further details as the ICC prosecutor is “duty bound” to protect the confidentiality of information received, it did confirm that a report had been made against Meloni and her ministers.

“Our Office usually does not comment on such communications, beyond confirming receipt if the sender has made the fact public. In this case, we can confirm receipt of the submission referred to in your question as the senders have made this fact public,” the court said.

Nationwide anti-Israel strikes on Sept. 22 and Oct. 3 called by two Italian trade unions, CGIL (Confederazione Generale Italiana del Lavoro) and USB (Unione Sindacale di Base), brought Italy to a halt.

Protesters blocked roads, threw stones and clashed with police.

Meloni told RAI of “a climate that is becoming significantly more barbaric” among “those who say that I and my government have blood on our hands.”

She appealed to a “sense of responsibility,” especially to “those who thought of stirring up a public outcry: Be careful, otherwise things will get out of hand.”

The protests, which also took place in other countries, revolved around Israeli naval actions against the Global Sumud Flotilla, which it seized on Oct. 1.

Israel had asked the flotilla of about 40 boats attempting to reach the Gaza Strip to change course, warning it was approaching an active combat zone and violating a lawful blockade.

Israel’s Foreign Ministry revealed that Hamas documents found in the Gaza Strip showed a direct link between the flotilla leaders and the Hamas terrorist organization.

While Italy has been more sympathetic to Israel than some European countries, refraining from recognizing a “State of Palestine,” it has joined in the criticism of Israel in international fora.

Addressing the 80th United Nations General Assembly general debate on Sept. 24, Meloni said that while the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack “drove Israel to what was in principle, a legitimate reaction,” it had crossed the line, “violating humanitarian norms,” which resulted in the “slaughter of civilians.”

Meloni said that Italy would therefore “vote in favor of some of the sanctions against Israel proposed by the European Commission.”

Israel has rejected accusations of targeting Gaza’s civilians, noting its efforts to move them out of harm’s way during combat operations, and the massive amounts of aid it has permitted into the Strip.

Explore Senior Israel Correspondent David Isaac’s expert analysis on Jewish history, politics, and current events at JNS.
“Opining on world affairs is not the job of a teachers’ union,” said Mika Hackner, director of research at the North American Values Institute.

“We’re launching a campaign to show the difference in the attitude towards Israel and towards Iran,” Daniel Meron, the Israeli ambassador to the United Nations in Geneva, told JNS.
Sara Brown, of the AJC, told JNS that “today we saw the very best of the democratic process.”
“Campaigns defined largely by opposition to AIPAC, our members and the values we represent continue to fall short on election night,” the pro-Israel group said.
Jewish organizations are urging Toronto police to lay hate charges after antisemitic caricatures of Jews were displayed at a Bathurst and Sheppard protest.
“It’s just absolutely critical that we get more funding appropriated, and at the same time, we also need to make sure that we break the log jam,” the Florida legislator said.