Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

‘Not Israel’s fault,’ says GOP senator of humanitarian crisis in Gaza

“It is totally in the hands of Hamas,” said Sen. Jim Risch of Idaho.

Humanitarian Aid to Gaza
A truck carrying aid on its way to the Gaza Strip from Israel, May 19, 2025. Credit: Flash90.

In a speech to Congress on Tuesday, Sen. Jim Risch (R-Idaho), chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, objected to a proposal by Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) that seeks to end Israel’s war against Hamas and its blockade of the Gaza Strip, saying the resolution doesn’t focus on who is to blame for the conflict.

“We have no disagreement about the suffering that’s going on in Gaza,” he said, regarding the Palestinian population there. “The problem we have here is, as we heard from both of these speakers, not one word was said as to whose fault this is. This is the fault of a group of people. And that group of people is Hamas.”

Risch rejected claims that the current humanitarian crisis in Gaza is the fault of Israel and the United States.

“I’ve heard them,” he said, referring to colleagues in the U.S. Senate, “mention Israel several times. This is not Israel’s fault. I heard them mention us, the United States. This is not our fault.”

“It is totally in the hands of Hamas,” he said, adding that “not one more bullet would be fired” if Hamas operatives released the estimated 58 hostages they have held in captivity since the terrorist attacks in southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, and laid down their weapons.

Risch also said it “doesn’t matter” if the United States sends aid while Hamas is still in power because the terror group steals it for its fighters, leaving women and children to suffer.

In 2024, Welch, the senator who sponsored the resolution, urged the Biden administration to stop military aid to Israel, arguing that the Jewish state had “met its objectives” in Gaza.

Mark Levine told The New York Times that he “still supports Israel but that the bonds aren’t strong enough investments.”
Israel’s foreign minister called it a historic day for ties between the two countries and an important day for the capital.
“I am proud to lead a tremendous revolution in settlement in Judea and Samaria and to effectively kill the idea of a Palestinian state,” Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich told JNS.
“Both sides were talking about the Michigan Senate race, the Shia leadership of Lebanon and the Jewish leadership of Israel,” Sen. James Lankford said.