Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

UN chief to place Israel on ‘list of shame’

António Guterres to put state on blacklist of parties committing major violations against children during war.

U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres
U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres at E.U. headquarters in Brussels, May 16, 2018. Photo by Alexandros Michailidis/Shutterstock.

In a move certain to exacerbate tensions between Jerusalem and the United Nations, Secretary-General António Guterres will place Israel on its annual so-called list of shame.

Each year, Guterres compiles a list of countries and armed groups he deems to have committed grave violations against children during conflict, and delivers a report on the matter to the U.N. Security Council in mid-July.

A senior Israeli diplomatic official confirmed to JNS an earlier media report that Guterres has informed Israel of his decision.

“Today the U.N. added itself to the black list of history when it joined those who support the Hamas murderers,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated, per an English translation that his office provided. “The IDF is the most moral army in the world; no delusional U.N. decision will change that.”

While the list carries no penalties, the fallout could be immensely damaging, with Israel at risk of decreased diplomatic standing and in jeopardy of sanctions, arms embargoes and other boycotts.

Sixty-six countries and groups, including Russia and the Myanmar military, appeared on last year’s list, as Guterres resisted pressure to add Israel. But, the high youth casualty toll Hamas claims Gazans have suffered from Israel’s counteroffensive following Hamas’s Oct. 7 massacre, combined with the increasingly deteriorating relationship between Guterres and the Israeli government, appears to have factored into his decision.

Stéphane Dujarric, a spokesman for Guterres, refused to comment to JNS or confirm Guterres’s decision, other than to say, “We can expect the report to go to the Security Council on its due date.”

A spokesman for the Israeli mission to the United Nations also declined comment.

While it appears the Israeli government is planning a response to the report’s release following months of failed talks and pressure on the subject, the head of the Israeli opposition, Yesh Atid Party leader Yair Lapid, said in a statement that “putting the State of Israel on the blacklist is a serious and baseless political step by the U.N. secretary-general, who has long since lost all moral direction.”

While blaming the Netanyahu government that Lapid claims “has lost all ability to stop Israel’s political deterioration,” he pointed out Hamas’s murder of “over 1,400 innocent citizens, women and children” by terrorist wretches who still hold young women and old people captive.”

Mike Wagenheim is a Washington-based correspondent for JNS, primarily covering the U.S. State Department and Congress. He is the senior U.S. correspondent at the Israel-based i24NEWS TV network.
“When journalists make these requests, they’re really made on behalf of the public, not to bury the issue and respond 11 months later,” Randy Mastro, a former deputy New York City mayor, told JNS.
“Under any Republican administration, Israelis are never going to be sanctioned for simply advocating against aid to Hamas or advocating against illegal Palestinian construction,” Eugene Kontorovich, a law professor, told JNS.
The USAID Inspector General’s office is “also working to prevent Hamas-linked staff from jumping to other aid organizations operating in Gaza,” a senior Trump admin official told JNS.
“Regardless of how it is ultimately classified, incidents like this send shockwaves through the Jewish community,” Rabbi Noah Farkas of Jewish Federation Los Angeles told JNS.
Prosecutors said the man caused damage to both facilities before sending texts boasting about the vandalism.
Despite Israeli objections to previously reported terms, the official said Washington is confident that all U.S. allies “will get on board” with the emerging agreement.