Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Red Cross compares Palestinian security prisoners with Israeli hostages

“Since October 7, Israel has suspended visits to the Palestinian prisoners in the prisons. At the same time, Hamas has so far not allowed visits to the abductees it is holding. This is unacceptable.”

A Hamas terrorist releases Israeli hostages to the Red Cross, in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip
A Hamas terrorist releases Israeli hostages to the Red Cross, in Rafah, the southern Gaza Strip, Nov. 28, 2023. Credit: Flash90.

A senior Red Cross official on Wednesday compared Israel with the Hamas terrorist organization, saying that both sides refuse to allow visitations for prisoners.

Hamas is holding 136 hostages captured during its Oct. 7 assault on the northwestern Negev.

“Since October 7, Israel has suspended visits to the Palestinian prisoners in the prisons. At the same time, Hamas has so far not allowed visits to the abductees it is holding. This is unacceptable,” Red Cross Regional Director for the Near and Middle East Fabrizio Carboni said in an interview with London-based Arabic-language newspaper Asharq Al-Awsat.

Carboni said that the International Red Cross visits Palestinian security prisoners in Israel and facilitates visits by their families, pointing an accusatory finger at Israel: “As of October 7, the Israeli authorities made a decision to suspend the visits through the International Red Cross. We regret this and continue to talk to those concerned to resume these visits.”

He added that “it is also sad that Hamas does not allow us to visit the abductees it is holding.”

Red Cross President Mirjana Spoljaric in December also blamed Israel, telling Channel 12 that “both” Hamas and Israel were responsible for the ICRC’s failure to reach the hostages.

Since Oct. 7, the International Red Cross has been helping imprisoned Palestinian terrorists receive controversial stipends from the Palestinian Authority, according to Israeli NGO Palestinian Media Watch.

According to PMW, incarcerated Palestinians fill out forms to receive the stipends, and the Red Cross delivers the paperwork to Ramallah.

Israeli rights organization Shurat HaDin last month announced the filing of a 10 million shekel (nearly $2.8 million) lawsuit on behalf of 24 plaintiffs against the International Committee of the Red Cross.

Filed in the Jerusalem District Court, the lawsuit accuses the Geneva-based ICRC of delaying action in the aftermath of Hamas’s Oct.7 massacre, and failing to visit or provide medical assistance to the hostages held by the terrorist group.

Israeli hostages in Gaza were supposed to receive badly needed medicines that entered the Strip nearly one week ago as part of a Qatari-French deal, but there is no evidence that the medicines reached them.

“If we marginalize ourselves from the mainstream of our people, the Jewish people and the Jewish state will continue without us,” the senior rabbi of Stephen Wise Free Synagogue said at the event.
“We expect a strong demand and will also offer a livestream to make the event accessible to a wider audience,” the museum stated.
“This is an important, if overdue, step toward protecting a knowledge space that should represent historical complexity rather than politicized framing,” Shlomit Lir of the University of Haifa told JNS.
‘We are not messing around with security at this year’s parade,’ Jessica Tisch, commisssioner of the New York City Police Department, told reporters.
Mark Goldfeder, of the National Jewish Advocacy Center, told JNS that it is “unbelievable” that the police did not immediately classify the incident as a hate crime.
“Oh, thank God. Esther is found safe,” stated Pierre Poilievre, leader of the Conservative Party. “What a blessed relief for her loved ones.”