Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Israel Police Commissioner: Social media inciters should be banned during extreme escalations

Insp. Gen. Yaakov Shabtai says that in times of major conflict, it may be necessary to block those fomenting violence online in order to save lives.

Chief of Police Kobi Shabtai arrives at a ceremony after a large police operation against illegal gun dealers, in Ma'ale Adumim, Sept. 7, 2022. Credit: Oren Ben Hakoon/Flash90
Chief of Police Kobi Shabtai arrives at a ceremony after a large police operation against illegal gun dealers, in Ma’ale Adumim, Sept. 7, 2022. Credit: Oren Ben Hakoon/Flash90

Social media networks are used during extreme scenarios to promote terrorism inside the State of Israel and organize mass street violence, Israel’s police chief warned on Wednesday, adding that in such extreme cases a temporary ban should be placed on inciters in order to save lives.

In a statement issued by the Israel Police, Insp. Gen. Yaakov Shabtai clarified that his comments referred to “the most extreme scenario, in which there is a danger to Israeli democracy and to state security, in which there is a mass uprising combined with broad terrorist elements within the State of Israel.”

In May 2021, such a scenario unfolded during mass disturbances in parts of the Arab Israeli sector, particularly in mixed Jewish-Arab cities, and police initially struggled to muster a response after being stretched beyond breaking point.

“The inspector-general was referring to blocking inciters calling for terror attacks and mass street disturbances, in which there are hundreds and thousands of such calls that further foment the incident,” police stated.

Responding to criticism of his remarks, Shabtai clarified that “at no stage was there an intention to restrict the movements of Israeli citizens. Rather, this would be a pinpoint and temporary step, that would certainly be taken with authority, to protect the lives of citizens and Israeli democracy during times of national emergencies, which endanger state security.”

“There’s no reason that the process can’t be dramatically accelerated,” Dan Schnur, a political science lecturer, told JNS.
Katie Wilson, who promised when she was running for mayor to turn off cameras, said that she made the decision after an intelligence briefing from local and federal law enforcement.
“It is troubling that a stadium supported by taxpayer dollars would openly subsidize an event led by an artist known for pushing this dangerous, hateful rhetoric, especially with Florida having one of the largest Jewish populations in our country,” Sen. Rick Scott stated.
Toronto’s police chief said that there will be more barricades and officers in an effort to prevent a repeat of last year’s “gauntlet of hate” near the walk.
Mika Hackner of the North American Values Institute told JNS that “particular attention should be paid to the ‘local institutions’ tasked with carrying on” the foundation’s programs.
The House Armed Services Committee rejected Rep. Ro Khanna’s amendment to delete section 224 from the annual defense bill, which calls for increased cooperation between the U.S. and Israel.