Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Hamburg public prosecutor blames mental illness for attack on Jewish student

AJC Berlin said on Twitter that it demands Hamburg prosecutors “not to belittle anti-Semitism & to depoliticize acts of violence.”

The Hohe Weide Synagogue in Hamburg, Germany. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.
The Hohe Weide Synagogue in Hamburg, Germany. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

The American Jewish Committee is demanding the Hamburg public prosecutor’s office to reconsider its ruling that an anti-Semitic attack on a German Jewish student was due to mental illness.

Last October, a 26-year-old German Jewish student wearing a kipah was beaten in front of the Hohe Weide Synagogue in Hamburg’s Eimsbüttel district by a man who had a hand-drawn swastika in his pocket. The 29-year-old attacker, later arrested by police, repeatedly struck the student on the head with a shovel outside the synagogue as the Jewish community celebrated the holiday of Sukkot.

A police spokesman cited by Germany’s news agency Deutsche Presse-Agentur said the suspect, a German of Kazakh origin, appeared to be in a confused state when they tried questioning him.

At the time, German Chancellor Angela Merkel called the incident a “disgrace.” Foreign Minister Heiko Maas classified it as “repugnant anti-Semitism.”

However, Hamburg’s public prosecutor recently ruled that “there is no evidence of a political motive,” describing the perpetrator as a victim of “delusional fears of persecution” because he believed that Jews were trying to kill him.

AJC Berlin said on Twitter that it demands Hamburg prosecutors “not to belittle anti-Semitism & to depoliticize acts of violence.”

The U.S. branch added: “The prosecution blames mental illness for the crime. We join @AJCBerlin in calling for the attack to be recognized for what it is: an act of Jew-hatred.”

“You couldn’t measure on a Richter scale the concern about El-Sayed,” the Jewish Federations of North America CEO said of the senator-elect from Michigan.
Xiao Junzheng defended Beijing’s ties to Tehran, but said ‘Israel is a friend of China.’
“This was more than solidarity. It was a refusal to let history repeat itself,” Jayne Zirkle of End Jew-Hatred told JNS.
Claudia Roth, 71, calling her remarks a “huge mistake” and a “great stupidity.”