Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

New Jersey defamation suit to proceed in case of Jewish teacher smeared online

“Ms. Muhammad must be held accountable for the significant trauma she has inflicted,” said Benjamin Ryberg, COO of the Lawfare Project.

Ibtihaj Muhammad
Ibtihaj Muhammad of the United States in the team event of the 2014-15 Orléans World Cup in women’s sabre, Nov. 23, 2014. Credit: Marie-Lan Nguyen via Wikimedia Commons.
Ibtihaj Muhammad
Ibtihaj Muhammad of the United States in the team event of the 2014-15 Orléans World Cup in women’s sabre, Nov. 23, 2014. Credit: Marie-Lan Nguyen via Wikimedia Commons.

A case can move forward to restore the reputation of Tamar Herman, a veteran teacher in the South Orange-Maplewood School District in New Jersey, after online accusations by Olympic fencer and author Ibtihaj Muhammad that she discriminated against a Muslim second-grade student by asking her to remove her hijab.

The Lawfare Project announced on Monday that the New Jersey Appellate Division had rejected a motion for dismissal and upheld the defamation lawsuit the group had filed in support of Herman.

“These accusations—published to Ms. Muhammad’s hundreds of thousands of social-media followers—led to widespread antisemitic attacks, physical threats and irreparable damage to Ms. Herman’s career and personal life,” the Lawfare Project stated.

“The malicious defamation campaign against Ms. Herman was a calculated, antisemitic effort to harm a respected member of the community, motivated by her Jewish identity,” said Benjamin Ryberg, COO of the Lawfare Project. “Ms. Muhammad must be held accountable for the significant trauma she has inflicted.”

The promotion of one of the president’s most partisan and hard-nosed lieutenants to one of the most powerful jobs in Washington may signal how Trump intends to respond to his party’s defeat in the midterms.
“It’s an evolving trend that shows greater signs of permanence than temporary quality,” Dan Diker of the Jerusalem Center for Foreign Affairs told JNS.
“She’s young. She’s dumb. She deserves an opportunity to become a better person,” Liz Benichou told JNS. “The only way to do that is through accountability.”
“The most powerful response we can offer is not conflict but proudly and peacefully enjoying the food, atmosphere and togetherness that these wonderful businesses bring to Philadelphia,” the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia said.