Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Canary Mission identifies Within Our Lifetime member who assaulted Israel supporter

Video points to the assailant as Saadah Masoud, who reportedly “has a history of violence and of physically assaulting Israel supporters.”

Matt Greenman of New York (left) was assaulted at a rally outside Israel’s consulate and Permanent Mission to the United Nations in Midtown Manhattan on April 20, 2022. Source: StopAntisemitism.org.
Matt Greenman of New York (left) was assaulted at a rally outside Israel’s consulate and Permanent Mission to the United Nations in Midtown Manhattan on April 20, 2022. Source: StopAntisemitism.org.

Jewish groups are demanding that authorities in New York take action against the man they claim assaulted a Jewish Israel supporter at an anti-Israel rally in April.

Matt Greenman was draped in an Israeli flag and standing outside Israel’s consulate and Permanent Mission to the United Nations in Midtown Manhattan on April 20 when the incident took place. He had gone to silently protest the rally “to support Palestinian resistance and liberation by any means necessary,” which was sponsored by a number of groups including Within Our Lifetime, Palestinian Youth Movement and Samidoun.

Greenman was treated at a local emergency room for his injuries.

In video footage, Canary Mission alleges that the assailant is Saadah Masoud, a member of Within Our Lifetime who they say “has a history of violence and of physically assaulting Israel supporters.”

Canary Mission said Masoud previously led a group of anti-Israel protesters in New York in attacking two Israel supporters and punching one of the men in the head. That assault in May 2021 came during an anti-Israel protest during the 11-day conflict between Israel and Hamas, during which the Gaza-based Palestinian terror group fired more than 4,000 rockets at civilian populations in Israel.

“Masoud’s continued presence at WOL rallies represents a physical threat to the New York public,” the statement continued. “It is deeply concerning that nothing has thus far been done to protect the public, in particular supporters of Israel, from this potentially dangerous individual.”

StopAntisemitism.org also took notice of Masoud’s actions, tweeting, “Jews in NYC are not safe with this violent bigot roaming the streets.” They tagged New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, New York City Mayor Eric Adams and Rep. Lee Zeldin (R-N.Y.) to their post.

The New York City Police Department is investigating the case; as of yet, there have been no arrests.

“Jewish New Yorkers constitute a minority of New Yorkers across the five boroughs and yet constitute a majority of New Yorkers who face hate crimes in this city,” the New York City mayor said.
“These disturbing incidents further reinforce the importance of clear and transparent safe-access policies,” said Mark Treyger, CEO of the Jewish Community Relations Council of New York.
“Let’s stand together for public safety, common sense and the future of our city,” Michael Novakhov, a Brooklyn representative, said.
“Since our nation’s founding 250 years ago, Jewish people have played an important role in America’s story,” the statement issued by the Republican Governors Association read.
Leo Terrell criticized city leaders and called for enforcement action after a protest outside Young Israel of Midwood led to arrests and renewed concern over antisemitic harassment in New York City.
The Captain America, Avengers and Hulk creator is “widely recognized as the most prolific and arguably most important creator in the history of the comic book,” a Center for Jewish History exhibit says.