Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Israeli High Court: Hamas prisoners not entitled to family visits

The court has rejected a petition by Hamas representatives seeking to overturn a 2017 decision by Public Security Minister Gilad Erdan canceling family visitations for Hamas terrorists in Israeli prisons.

Ofer Prison near Jerusalem. Photo by Christopher Michel via Wikimedia Commons.
Ofer Prison near Jerusalem. Photo by Christopher Michel via Wikimedia Commons.

Israel’s High Court of Justice has rejected a petition by Hamas terrorists from Gaza incarcerated in Israeli prisons to overrule a decision by Israeli Public Security Minister Gilad Erdan to prevent them from receiving family visits.

In 2017, Erdan ordered the Israel Prison Service not to approve family visits for Gaza terrorists connected to Hamas in a bid to exert pressure on the organization to return Israeli citizens and the bodies of Israeli soldiers.

The court found that Erdan’s decision fell within the purview of state security and is legal, according to The Jerusalem Post.

“It is unreasonable and immoral to allow despicable terrorists to have family visits as long as Hamas holds the bodies of our soldiers and Israeli citizens,” said Erdan. “I welcome the High Court of Justice’s ruling rejecting the petition against my decision. ... I will continue to act against the terrorists in prison until their prison terms fall to the minimum required by law.”

In a statement, the family of IDF Lt. Hadar Goldin, whose body has been held captive by Hamas since the 2014 Gaza War, said, “We now expect Netanyahu to toughen the conditions of the prisoners and put effective pressure on Hamas. If the government of Israel implements and fulfills the Cabinet’s decisions, we will be able to bring Hadar, Oron [Shaul], Avera [Mengistu] and Hisham [al-Sayed] back home in the best agreement since the end of the Yom Kippur War.”

Mari Leavitt, a Democratic state representative, told JNS that the public university “used extremely poor judgment” by inviting Piker and erred by not including mention of Piker’s “dangerous rhetoric” in the initial event announcement.
“I’m seeing what’s going on in New York,” Stav Cohen, founder of the Israeli nonprofit Frontline Advocates, told JNS. “I fear for my speakers’ lives.”
The “Associated Press” called the race for Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan about two hours after polls closed.
State Assembly member Francesca Hong, who has accused Israel of “genocide,” lost the Democratic primary after polls suggested that she held a double-digit lead.