Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Israeli court rules terrorists’ bodies may be held for hostage deals

The decision backs the government’s stance on the matter.

Acting President of the Israeli Supreme Court Uzi Vogelman and fellow justices arrive at a hearing in Jerusalem on June 18, 2023. Credit: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.
Acting President of the Israeli Supreme Court Uzi Vogelman and fellow justices arrive at a hearing in Jerusalem on June 18, 2023. Credit: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.

Israel’s High Court of Justice unanimously ruled on Sunday that the state is not required to release for burial the bodies of terrorists who are Israeli citizens.

This decision aligns with the state’s stance that these remains could be used in potential negotiations for the return of Israeli hostages and fallen soldiers currently held by Hamas in Gaza.

The ruling came after six petitions from the terrorists’ families, who argued that withholding the bodies violated the law and harmed the dignity of the dead and their relatives.

The state countered that ongoing negotiations are sensitive and dynamic, making the retention of these bodies a potential necessity for future exchanges.

Justice David Mintz emphasized that intervention in security-related government decisions is extremely limited.

He noted that military commanders have the authority under a 1945 regulation to withhold the release of such bodies and that the policy is temporary and reviewed periodically by the cabinet. Given the current security situation and the nature of the ongoing negotiations with Hamas, the court found no grounds to intervene.

“This political environment could discourage congressional committee staff and federal agency personnel from pursuing investigations or enforcement actions involving antisemitism,” Karen Paikin Barall of the Brandeis Center told JNS.
The Nachala Movement says 1,500 families are waiting to move into the Strip, as supporters call for the renewal of communities dismantled in 2005.
Q&A
In a wide-ranging pre-election interview with JNS, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu discusses his alliance with U.S. President Donald Trump; the necessity to act against Iran; expand the Abraham Accords; tackle domestic challenges, including reintroducing judicial reforms; and further strengthening the Israeli economy.
“There is not, and there will not be, a Palestinian state,” the Israeli prime minister pledged. He also called for the corruption trial against him to be dropped.