When Jews gather in synagogues on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur this month, will their rabbis seek to rally them to stand with Israel and against the surge of antisemitism fueled by blood libels against the Jewish state? Or will they instead use their pulpits to virtue-signal their support for false charges of “genocide” being hurled at Jerusalem? Those are the questions that JNS editor-in-chief Jonathan Tobin is posing.
He’s joined in this week’s episode of “Think Twice” by Rabbi Stuart Weinblatt, chair of the Rabbinic Zionist Coalition, who lamented the fact that so many Jews rely on outlets like The New York Times and NPR for news, which base their coverage on an uncritical acceptance of an anti-Israel and pro-Hamas narrative. He says the coalition is needed more than ever now because, as the post-Oct. 7 war drags on with antisemitism growing, Israel needs the support of American Jewry and their spiritual leaders. He believes that the imperative for rabbis is to remember that “we should not allow our relationship with Israel to be defined or determined by Israel’s enemies.”
Weinblatt said he was concerned by the way a growing number of young rabbis are embracing an anti-Zionist agenda promulgated by opponents of the Jewish state. Their opinions were, he stated, as is the case with many young Americans, influenced by progressive ideologies that falsely labeled Jews and Israel as “white” oppressors.
Moreover, he said it was essential for all Jews to recognize the centrality of the land of Israel to Judaism. While some people focus on misleading allegations about Israeli behavior, even if some of the charges lodged against the Jewish state were true, “We do not love Israel because Israel is perfect, nor do we need Israel to be perfect for us to love her.”
The mainstreaming of antisemitic attitudes and blood libels is, he said, simply a reversion to the pre-Holocaust reality in which Jew-hatred was the norm.
He pointed out that many young rabbis are inspiring their congregants to have a stronger connection with Israel. But part of the problem is the way some of the seminaries that are educating rabbis are admitting to being open opponents of Israel’s existence—something he said they would not do if candidates for admission were homophobic or racist. These institutions do so because they are desperate for students and because they, too, are influenced by progressive attitudes about Israel.
Listen/Subscribe to weekly episodes on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube Music, iHeart Radio or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
Watch new episodes every week by subscribing to the JNS YouTube Channel.
