Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Irish man gets suspended sentence for threatening Jews in France

An Irish flag flying over Dublin. Photo by David Renton/Shutterstock.
An Irish flag flying over Dublin. Photo by David Renton/Shutterstock.

An Irish man was handed a suspended sentence of six months in prison for threatening to kill a Jewish person near Marseille in August, French media reported on Tuesday.

The man, identified in La Provence and other French media as Patrick O’Brien, 60, was filmed in Avignon in August telling an Australian Jewish couple that he regretted Adolf Hitler had not “finished the job,” expressing hope for Hitler’s return and threatening to shoot the woman in the head.

He admitted intending to hurt the couple verbally after realizing that the man was Jewish. In court, he described himself as a “great humanist,” La Provence said.

The Avignon court convicted him of glorifying crimes against humanity and making death threats aggravated by antisemitic prejudice. He was ordered to pay €500 ($556) to each victim and €300 ($333) to several civil-party organizations. The court rejected prosecutors’ request to ban him from French territory for three years.

A lawyer representing the victims, Annie Cohen, said the sentence was excessively lenient, La Provence reported, noting that the woman’s father was a Holocaust survivor.

The incident had attracted widespread attention in France after a video of the confrontation went viral in August.

See more from JNS Staff
“You meet people who think Netanyahu has been an extraordinary wartime leader, something no American I know would dare speak out loud, but still want him gone,” Reuven Fenton told JNS. “You meet others, who hold him responsible for Oct. 7 but don’t see a credible alternative.”
The country’s next government will depend on whether its political leaders can reconcile their competing commitments, or whether voters will again be asked to resolve a deadlock that negotiations could not.
Memories of Israel’s first national election on Jan. 25, 1949.
“The defendant has demonstrated that he poses a grave danger to children,” stated the U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of New York.