Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

‘Back to the 1930s': Outrage over online ‘mapping’ of Jewish, Israeli tourism in Italy

The effort to single out Jewish and Israeli tourists was widely condemned by Italian politicians across the political spectrum.

Italian Senate
Lawmakers attend a session at the Italian Senate in Rome on Oct. 4, 2017. Credit: Fratello Gracco via Wikimedia Commons.

An online campaign calling on people to surveil and report the whereabouts of Jewish and Israeli tourists, or anyone suspected of having ties to “Zionists,” has sparked anger among Israeli diplomats, local Jewish leaders and Italian politicians.

The anonymous campaign, focused in Milan, and spread via social media and messaging apps, involved a link which opened to a Google document. It asked questions to identify the exact locations of Jewish and Israeli individuals, including specific hotels, vacation rentals, and commercial establishments, to create what it called “a mapping of Zionist tourism.”

The information would be used for unspecified future initiatives, the form said.

“This form is intended to record cases of Zionist tourism, property purchases, and, more generally, Zionist neo-colonization in Italy,” according to the document. “The data collected will be received by the Global Sumud Movement and will remain protected and confidential.”

The Global Sumud Movement, which organizes anti-Israel activities in Europe, including the recent flotillas to the Gaza Strip, denied any involvement in the campaign following the backlash.

“I think we’re going back to the 1930s, to the hunt for Jews,” Milan Jewish Community President Walker Meghnagi said. “Mapping where Jews are is extremely serious.”

He called on the judiciary to intervene and for all parties to take a stand against the campaign.

Undersecretary of State to the Presidency of the Council of Ministers, Alessandro Morelli, a member of the conservative League Party, a junior partner in Italy’s ruling coalition, condemned the form as “abhorrent,” harking back to “the dark ages of Nazi-Fascism.”

He also called for the unanimous political condemnation of the “racist initiative.”

“We’re essentially talking about blacklists. We’re returning to the extremely dangerous climate that preceded the racial laws,” said Italian Senator Graziano Delrio of the Democratic Party, the main opposition party, referring to a series of antisemitic and segregationist decrees enacted by Benito Mussolini’s Fascist regime between 1938 and 1943.

Israeli Ambassador to Italy Jonathan Peled posted to X on Sunday, “The initiative to map Zionist tourism in Italy is an abominable action that highlights the alarming growth of antisemitic hatred in Italy and reveals, once again, the extremist and discriminatory drifts of the Pro-Pal movement.”

The European Jewish Congress, the main umbrella organization for Jewish communities across Europe, said of the questionnaire, “Presented as a ‘mapping of Zionist tourism,’ the initiative effectively encourages the identification and targeting of individuals based on their actual or perceived Jewish identity or nationality.

“Such attempts to single out individuals based on their identity create fear, fuel hatred and place Jewish communities at greater risk. The Italian authorities must act swiftly to ensure those responsible are held accountable and that such dangerous practices are stopped immediately,” it added.

David Isaac, an expert on Jewish history, politics and current events, is an Israel bureau correspondent for JNS.
CEO Yigal Dilmoni toured the devastated Samaria community before announcing an emergency fundraising drive for families who lost homes and businesses.
The Israeli Defense Ministry is drafting a plan to expand local weapons manufacturing and reduce reliance on foreign suppliers.
Applications had reached about three times the country’s average electricity consumption.
Dagan joined ambassadors from Switzerland and Honduras, and a representative of the Palestinians.
The tiny Pacific island country northeast of Australia is one of Israel’s most consistent supporters at the United Nations.
The United States would reportedly approve uranium enrichment only if a joint study concludes the move is justified.