Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Judge gives Jewish sailor temporary pass from US Navy order to shave beard

Edmund Di Liscia said that doing so would be “extremely humiliating and deeply jarring to my psyche and soul.”

U.S. Navy sailors. Credit: Anthony Correia/Shutterstock.
U.S. Navy sailors. Credit: Anthony Correia/Shutterstock.

A federal judge temporarily postponed on Thursday an order by the U.S. Navy to have a Jewish sailor shave his beard, reported Military.com.

Electrician’s Mate (Nuclear) 3rd Class Edmund Di Liscia, a Torah-observant Jew aboard the aircraft carrier Theodore Roosevelt, was ordered to shave his beard by Friday. He previously received a religious accommodation that allowed him to wear a beard in uniform, though was told by his ship’s command that the rule had been overridden.

Judge Timothy Kelly filed a temporary restraining order in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., that would prevent the U.S. Defense Department from being able to force the sailor to shave. Di Liscia wrote in his complaint that being ordered to do so violates his religious practices and would be “extremely humiliating and deeply jarring to my psyche and soul.”

In ordering the temporary stay, Kelly said with Di Liscia’s ship being halfway around the world, he wanted the Defense Department’s team to have more time to learn about the sailor’s situation.

Joseph Carilli Jr., who is representing the Defense Department, said Chief of Naval Personnel Vice Adm. John Nowell sent an order to Di Liscia’s superiors, instructing them to pause any move requiring the sailor to shave his beard.

Eric Baxter, an attorney with the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, said the Navy requiring Di Liscia to shave goes against the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the U.S. Constitution.

“If Michigan Hillel wants to remain the center of Jewish life on campus, it cannot retreat from one of the central and challenging parts of being Jewish there,” Seth Mendel, of CAMERA, told JNS.
Three other soldiers were lightly wounded when the military vehicle overturned.
Twenty British diplomats will leave Israel; seven remain under an agreement that pauses retaliation while talks continue.
Gideon Sa’ar urged unity, and warned that violence in Judea and Samaria is damaging ties with Israel’s closest friends.