Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Letter to IDF on questionable values signed by 200 rabbis

A group of rabbis, deans and teachers express concern over military policies they feel are not commensurate with Jewish values.

Israeli soldiers in the Neztah Yehuda Battalion (“Nahal Haredi”) complete the final stages of a 40-kilometer journey during the night on Feb. 16, 2010. Other military practices are being debated by a group of rabbis in Israel. Photo by Abir Sultan/Flash90.
Israeli soldiers in the Neztah Yehuda Battalion (“Nahal Haredi”) complete the final stages of a 40-kilometer journey during the night on Feb. 16, 2010. Other military practices are being debated by a group of rabbis in Israel. Photo by Abir Sultan/Flash90.

Some 200 religious Zionist rabbis signed a letter expressing their concern over Israel Defense Forces’ policies they feel are not commensurate with Jewish values.

Among the issues are a controversial update to protocol further integrating women into combat units.

The rabbis expressed their opposition to the policy, which will require men and women living and operating in close quarters.

Signatories included Rabbi Tzvi Tau, Rabbi Dov Lior, Rabbi Haim Shteiner and Jerusalem Chief Rabbi Aryeh Stern, as well as municipal chief rabbis, yeshivah deans and teachers, and rabbis from an array of other institutions.

They stated that they are “seeking to warn that in recent times, our beloved army is advancing extremist liberal cultural perspectives which are coming at the expense of the central purpose of the IDF, helping Israel against the enemy and our hold on our holy land, and is harming the holiness of the camp and the unity of the people.”

They also decried the inclusion of outside pluralistic organizations in army educational programs and efforts that would make it harder for religious girls to avoid military service through participation in the national service program.

Military sources say the national service exemption policy is meant to keep non-religious women from abusing the exemption by claiming to be religious.

“Disagreement with activities that are forbidden by our Torah, and are also in opposition to all healthy, human logic of behavior within an army framework, will prevent the IDF from descending into an ethical and human nadir,” the rabbis wrote. “In light of this, we seek to support our students and all IDF soldiers wherever they are to stand with determination and self-sacrifice for their ethical, humanitarian and Jewish-legal obligations in everything to do with mixing of the sexes and the holiness of the camp, wherever they come upon a demand which is not legitimate and not ethical.”

Toronto police arrested five individuals on charges including assaulting and obstructing officers, while another person was arrested for operating a drone in the area.
A USAID inspector general investigation recommended blacklisting 101 current and former agency staffers, including school teachers and medical professionals, from U.S. foreign-aid programs.
“It used to be that most of the people who called us were in their 50s, 60s and 70s,” David Greenfield told JNS. “We’re getting calls from people in their 20s now who can’t find jobs, who need help.”
“Israel has a full right to self-defense, and we are exercising it to the extent necessary,” the prime minister told the nation. “I say this to you, just as I say this, with appreciation and respect, in my good conversations with my friend President Trump.”
“This is the first time the EU has applied its new freedom of navigation regime and, when necessary, we will apply it again,” European Union foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said.
“The IDF will continue to operate in Lebanon against the terrorist organization Hezbollah,” stated Israel Katz in no uncertain terms.