Newsletter
Newsletter Support JNS

Jewish leaders, parents criticize New York Board of Ed meetings on Shabbat

Four town hall meetings, in addition to Zoom interviews for two people vying for a seat on a mayoral advisory board, took place on the Friday night before Memorial Day weekend.

New York City Department of Education
New York City Department of Education building. Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

New York City’s Department of Education is being slammed for scheduling a series of public events on Friday night when Shabbat-observant Jews were unable to attend.

“I am appalled that some parents are expected to violate their religious beliefs to be part of the town halls or be excluded from the process,” Effi Zakry wrote to New York City schools Chancellor David Banks, as reported by the New York Post.

Zakry is a member of the Citywide Council on High Schools (CCHS), which advocates for parents of public high school students and represents families in the borough of Queens.

On the evening of May 27, the DOE held four town hall meetings with school superintendent candidates in Brooklyn and Queens, in addition to Zoom interviews for two parents competing for a seat on a mayoral advisory board on education issues, according to the newspaper.

In his letter, Zakry accused the DOE of “religious discrimination” and claimed that the department has disregarded requests by observant Jews to prevent scheduling events on Shabbat.

He added that CCHS president Karen Wang has pointed this out several times and requested that the schedule be changed in order to respect the religious beliefs of Sabbath observers in New York City. “But no one at the DOE bothered to show such respect to the Jewish community. Both Brooklyn and Queens happen to have the largest observant Jewish populations in New York City,” said Zakry.

He also wrote to Banks that other than Jews, “some Christians and other groups observe the holy Sabbath.”

Moreover, scheduling the meetings on the Friday night of Memorial Day weekend “is also disrespectful to families who lost loved ones and want to celebrate Memorial Day.”

The DOE did not respond to a request for comment from JNS, though spokesman Nathaniel Styer told the New York Post that parent leaders “led the design of each town hall, including confirming the date that best works for their community.”

“It’s a great victory for the First Amendment right to free speech, including the right to draw attention to bigotry and hateful speech,” Paul Eckles, of the Brandeis Center, told JNS. “We commend our client for having the courage to speak out.”
U.S. President Donald Trump appears to have precipitated the move by demanding congressional action in a social media post earlier on Wednesday.
JNS sought comment from Aria Fani and received an autoreply, “On leave until September. Will not check email with capitalist frequency.”
A spokesman for the Ivy told JNS that the school believes being required “to create lists of Jewish faculty and staff, and to provide personal contact information, raises serious privacy and First Amendment concerns.”
The new program adds “America First foreign policy lectures” and shifts focus to merit and core diplomatic skills.
Police officers found evidence that Dejaun Angelo was running a marijuana business in his apartment and “hundreds of ammunition boxes” in a storage unit.