A few weeks ago, we witnessed the deadliest attack on American Jews in history. Eleven members of the Tree of Life*Or L’Simcha Synagogue in Pittsburgh were violently murdered because they were Jewish. I was shocked by this horror, but I was not surprised.
Anti-Semitism is as old as the Jewish story itself. We honor the victims of the Holocaust on Yom Hashoah, we remember our struggles as slaves in ancient Egypt on Passover, and we even celebrate triumph over Haman’s plans to slaughter us in ancient Persia on Purim. It’s the terrible truth that we live with the constant realization that radical groups want to eradicate our people and all that binds us together: our beliefs, our values, our culture, our history—and our homeland, Israel.
History has shown that anti-Semitism can reach us anywhere. As novelist Norman Mailer once said, “When the time comes, they won’t ask what kind of a Jew you are.” It doesn’t matter if you go to synagogue every day, every week, once a year or never in your life. It doesn’t matter whether you love U.S. President Donald Trump or you hate him. It doesn’t matter if you’re in Poland or you’re in Pittsburgh, and it doesn’t matter if you consider yourself a proud Jew or an assimilated one.
When we see anti-Semites acting out their hateful bigotry, we are confronted with a choice: What do we do? Do we condemn the evil and hope for the best? Do we stick our heads in the sand and ignore the ever-rising threats? Do we ask the government and other groups to defend us because we are passive or risk-averse? Do we turn our backs on the future of our people and allow history to repeat itself?
Or do we fight back? Do we proactively work to fight not just for love, tolerance or even acceptance, but to make it so that our children today—and their children tomorrow—will be prepared and capable to confront anti-Semites, and live safely and freely as Jews?
My wife and I traveled last year to Poland and saw the horrific conditions suffered by the Jews in Auschwitz-Birkenau, built with a single purpose: to exterminate our people.
Our takeaway from the trip was that we must be vigilant and fight against our enemies.
I previously wrote about how today’s anti-Semitism manifests itself as a three-headed monster. This monster spews its vile bigotry through the radical right, the radical left and radical Muslims. Each one of these hateful heads poses a real threat around the world. These radical groups work to divide our community to make us weaker and easier to target. We need to put aside our internal politics and band together, as proud Jews, finding the courage and strength to fight these groups.
How? First, we must closely learn about those who seek us harm. That means investing more resources into research capabilities, drawing on the latest technology to uncover the anti-Semitic networks online and offline. We must understand what anti-Semites are saying, what their plans are and how they operate. We must us this knowledge to expose their unlawful activities and better protect our Jewish institutions in partnership with law enforcement.
Second, we must fight the alarming progress of anti-Semitism from the extreme fringes of our public discourse into the mainstream. We must be vigilant in educating the public about the evil and true intentions of anti-Semitism, whether it is spewed by Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan, British Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbin or white supremacist David Duke. For too long, we have behaved as if anti-Semitism is merely distasteful, but not a danger. The Oct. 27 attack in Pittsburgh made very clear the stakes for us all. Journalists, politicians, celebrities and business leaders must be immediately called out when they echo anti-Semitic canards.
Third, we need to utilize the research acquired and to invest more in the physical security of our Jewish schools, synagogues and other institutions. As Jews, we cannot ignore the fact that we are all targets.
Jews don’t have to be like sheep led to the slaughter. Unlike many of our communities in the past, we have civil and human rights—the right to vote and serve in the government, and the ability to fight back.
We are a proud people with a long memory who live in a time with a strong and thriving Jewish state. We don’t have to be afraid and passive. We shouldn’t stay beneath the radar to maintain our pristine and nice reputation. We must be proactive and fight this head on.
Adam Milstein is an Israeli-American philanthropist. He can be reached at [email protected].
Be a part of our community
JNS serves as the central hub for a thriving community of readers who appreciate the invaluable context our coverage offers on Israel and their Jewish world.
Please join our community and help support our unique brand of Jewish journalism that makes sense.