This 2024 - Let's Win the Battle of Headlines
OpinionMiddle East

Muslims and Jews: The ‘original grudge’ theory

French psychoanalyst, philosopher and author Daniel Sibony is to be commended for boldly swimming against a tide of denial and distortion regarding Jewish-Muslim relations.

The Middle East as seen from 250 miles above in this April 14, 2016 photo from the International Space Station. Countries seen, from left, along the Mediterranean coast include Egypt, Gaza, Saudi Arabia, Israel, Lebanon, Syria and Turkey. Credit: NASA via Wikimedia Commons.
The Middle East as seen from 250 miles above in this April 14, 2016 photo from the International Space Station. Countries seen, from left, along the Mediterranean coast include Egypt, Gaza, Saudi Arabia, Israel, Lebanon, Syria and Turkey. Credit: NASA via Wikimedia Commons.
Lyn Julius
Lyn Julius is the author of "Uprooted: How 3,000 Years of Jewish Civilization in the Arab World Vanished Overnight" (Vallentine Mitchell, 2018).

In 2013, Princeton University Press published “A History of Jewish-Muslim Relations: From the Origins to the Present Day,” the first encyclopaedia on the history of relations between Jews and Muslims from the birth of Islam to the present day. Edited by Abdelwahab Meddeb and Benjamin Stora, the encyclopaedia is a glossy coffee-table book featuring more than 150 articles by an international team of leading experts. Its stated objective was “greater historical understanding and a more informed dialogue between Jews and Muslims.”

One man, however, was not impressed. Daniel Sibony is a French psychoanalyst and philosopher, and the author of no less than 26 books, most unfortunately not available in English. Sibony believed that “greater understanding” and “informed dialogue” meant idealizing the true nature of Jewish-Muslim relations during 13 centuries of “coexistence.” He set out his response to Meddeb and Stora in a book called “Un certain vivre-ensemble: musulmans et juifs dans le monde arabe.”

The book’s message may be summed up as follows: “Tell me who you despise, and I’ll tell you who you are.”

Sibony argues that the Muslim bears the non-Muslim Other an “original grudge,” which has colored Muslim relations with the Jews living among them since the Koran was written in the 7th century. The “grudge” has helped define Muslim identity, he claims.

Going back to Mohammed’s encounter with the Jewish tribes of Arabia, the grudge, says Sibony, consists of resentment of the Jews for “betraying” Mohammed by refusing to follow his new religion. And, he adds, there is the lingering resentment that the Jews were first out with their Holy Book.

In the Muslim mind, argues Sibony, the Jew is cursed by his primordial failure to convert. In fact the very term “Jew”—with its associations of uncleanliness and femininity—was an insult in Morocco, ne notes. The Jew is condemned to inferior, dhimmi status, a system of humiliating handicaps and strictures. He is banned from reading the Koran, in case he should criticize it. To argue that the colonial era in Arab lands marked a divorce between Jews and Arabs assumes that there was a marriage in the first place.

Non-Muslims kept the Islamic world afloat through payment of the jizya tax. The ruler levied this tax in order to “protect” the Jews. But protect from whom? A hostile populace which had assimilated the lessons of the Koran and the “original grudge.”

Living in the Marrakech medina in Morocco until he left for France at age 13, Sibony knew the power of the mob. Riots would erupt around the time of the Jewish festivals, to the extent that one Jewish mother preparing her daughter’s wedding sought reassurance from a neighbor that his co-religionists were not planning to disrupt the festivities. The ruler could turn the screw on his Jews when he needed them to pay heavier taxes, while threatening to unleash popular violence on them. Today’s jihadists, too, Sibony argues, are essentially mobsters.

The Meddeb-Stora encyclopaedia vaunts the cross-cultural Golden Age in Spain as evidence of harmonious Jewish-Muslim coexistence. But Sibony argues that even a slave can enjoy a good night’s sleep when he takes off his leg-irons. The encyclopedia, he says, emphasizes the positive exception to the rule.

There are plenty of Jews from Morocco willing to testify to the good relations there between Jews and Muslims. One reason was that the mob never penetrated the richer quarters, protected by the police—their Jewish residents were insulated from trouble.

Sibony claims that Jews did not want to dwell on the negative: they were too busy living life to the full—a life filled with music, poetry, ritual and faith. Besides, their childhoods were marked by the hope that they would soon be leaving. There were times when Muslims, too, forgot their “grudge”—but it was always there in the background, like a radio whose volume knob had been turned down. The ultimate proof that all was not well between the two communities is the massive exodus of Jews from Arab lands.

Sibony’s thesis may be criticized for putting too much emphasis on a dhimmi status abrogated by the colonial era, and for ignoring the influence of European and Nazi anti-Semitism in the Arab world. But in Morocco the colonial period was shorter than most, and Sibony still remembers seeing Jews wearing the discriminatory black djellaba in his native Marrakesh. He should be commended for boldly swimming against a tide of denial and distortion.

Lyn Julius is the author of “Uprooted: How 3,000 years of Jewish Civilization in the Arab World Vanished Overnight” (Vallentine Mitchell, 2018).

The opinions and facts presented in this article are those of the author, and neither JNS nor its partners assume any responsibility for them.
You have read 3 articles this month.
Register to receive full access to JNS.

Just before you scroll on...

Israel is at war.

JNS is combating the stream of misinformation on Israel with real, honest and factual reporting. In order to deliver this in-depth, unbiased coverage of Israel and the Jewish world, we rely on readers like you.

The support you provide allows our journalists to deliver the truth, free from bias and hidden agendas. Can we count on your support?

Every contribution, big or small, helps JNS.org remain a trusted source of news you can rely on.

Become a part of our mission by donating today
Topics
Comments
Thank you. You are a loyal JNS Reader.
You have read more than 10 articles this month.
Please register for full access to continue reading and post comments.
Never miss a thing
Get the best stories faster with JNS breaking news updates