Don’t break quarantine in the name of Judaism

There is no basis in Judaism for saying: “I trust in God and therefore I can ignore medical advice.” To the contrary, the same God who tells us to fast on Yom Kippur or go to synagogue tells us that to protect our health, we are required to eat on Yom Kippur or stay away from the synagogue.

A Jewish man walks at the almost empty Western Wall, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 27, 2020. Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.
A Jewish man walks at the almost empty Western Wall, in the Old City of Jerusalem, March 27, 2020. Photo by Yonatan Sindel/Flash90.
Rabbi Yossi Marcus
Yossi Marcus

“A clever person sees evil and hides, but simpletons pass on and are punished” — Proverbs 22:3.

This verse was cited by Rabbi Menachem Mendel Horodoker, writing from Tiberias in the aftermath of an epidemic in 1786. Nine years earlier, this Rebbe, leader of the third generation of Chassidim, led a group of 300 olim to the Holy Land.

In a fascinating and moving letter, he describes how he and his compatriots survived an epidemic that ravaged the area. Both in the timing of the events, which “lasted from the days of Purim until the beginning of [the Hebrew month of ] Iyar,” and the experience he describes, Rabbi Horodoker’s narrative resonates for us more than 200 years later.

He cites another biblical verse, from Isaiah, as the recommended protocol during a pandemic: “Go, my people, enter your rooms and close your door behind you; hide for a brief moment until the wrath has passed” (Isaiah 26:20). Those who sequestered themselves in their courtyards, he writes, survived for the most part, while “the plague eventually caught up with those who fled, because the plague was in the people like a consuming flame. Many lives were lost in just a few days, from the Sephardi and Ashkenazi communities alike.”

He attributes his own survival to his decision to shelter in place, and to God. “Miraculously, by God’s wonders,” he wrote, “we were saved from harm and provided with all our needs during the quarantine. In the streets one could only see people who are empty and reckless. Our friends who live in Peki’in (approximately 40 km from Tiberias) fled to the mountains and sequestered themselves in the caves. They managed to save their lives. Their homes, however, they lost to looters.”

For this deeply pious Rebbe, author of the profound and mystical work Pri Ha’aretz, there was no tension between absolute faith in God and prudent behavior during an epidemic. He was following thousands of years of Torah tradition, which tells us to “break one Shabbat [to save a life] so that you will be able to celebrate many more in the future.” The Talmud devotes considerable space to dispelling the notion that religious practice should lead us to ignore medical advice.

‘Don’t tell me I can’t fast’

I’m reminded of the story told by Rabbi Manis Friedman, who was once approached by a Jew from Russia a few days before Yom Kippur. “Rabbi,” said the stranger, “my doctor told me I should not fast this Yom Kippur, but I’m not going to listen to him. I fasted every Yom Kippur for the past 60 years, and I’ll do the same this year!”

Rabbi Friedman patiently explained to him that according to Jewish law one is required to heed doctors’ advice. (The rabbi may have cited the story of Rabbi Yisrael of Salant, Lithuania, who during a cholera outbreak in 1848, got up in front of the synagogue on Yom Kippur and ate in front of the whole congregation, since fasting could make one more vulnerable to the disease.)

Still, the man would not relent: “Let me tell you what happened to me when I was in the Russian army. One Yom Kippur, at the end of fasting the whole day, I was about to break my fast when I found out that I had fasted one day early, and in fact Yom Kippur was beginning!”

“So what did you do?”

“What did I do? I kept right on fasting for a second day straight. And now I should eat on Yom Kippur because of some doctor?”

The wise rabbi saw his opportunity: “My dear friend, don’t you see? God arranged for you to fast twice in your youth so you wouldn’t have to fast this year.”

There is no basis in Judaism for saying: “I trust in God and therefore I can ignore medical advice.” To the contrary, the same God who tells us to fast on Yom Kippur, or go to the synagogue, tells us that to protect our health, we are required to eat on Yom Kippur, or stay away from the synagogue.

‘The problematic pail’

I’m reminded of another story, about two contemporaries of the aforementioned Rabbi Horodoker: the famed Chassidic masters Rabbi Elimelech of Lizensk and his brother Rabbi Zushe of Anipoli. These two humble mystics found themselves imprisoned one night through no fault of their own. In the morning, Rabbi Zushe wanted to pray with his tefillin but couldn’t do so because of a certain pail that was provided as the cell’s bathroom. He gently asked the warden to remove it so that he could pray in a clean room but was laughed off. He began to cry. His brother said to him, “Zushe! The same God who commands us to don tefillin each day, commands us not to don tefillin in this situation. So why the long face? Every other day you fulfill the divine will by donning tefillin; today you’ll do so by not donning tefillin.”

“You have a point,” said Reb Zushe. As his brother’s perspective sunk in, Reb Zushe was filled with incredible joy and started to dance. When the other prisoners saw him dancing, they joined in. Suddenly, the cell was hopping, drawing the attention of the head warden, who asked the warden to explain what was going on. “I don’t know,” said the confused warden, “but I think it has something to do with that pail.” The impatient boss yelled at his underling, “So take it out!”


We are living in unprecedented times. For the first time in history we are shutting everything down, not to save our lives necessarily, but to save those most vulnerable and to protect our medical establishment.

If we travel back a few thousand years, it’s hard to imagine that societies that practiced infanticide and gladiator sports, would take the precautions we are taking today to protect the vulnerable.

We cannot know the Divine reason for these things and it would be foolish for anyone to claim otherwise. But we can reflect on what messages we might derive from them. One obvious message is that these events have enabled us to see how far we’ve come. The sanctity of every life, an idea that Judaism taught thousands of years ago, is now a given throughout most of the world.

Perhaps it is also a correction for our hubris, our belief that we are gods, that we are in total control. Or maybe we are getting a big “Slow Down” sign, and if you have kids at home, maybe it says “Children at Play”—spend some time with them. Stop running from here to there. Sit with yourself a bit. Stop distracting yourself.

And as bad as this is, let’s remember that we’ve survived and rebuilt after worse. We will survive and rebuild after this one, hopefully in a world that is cleaner, physically and spiritually.

Yet with all the silver linings, there have been too many deaths, too many taken ill, too many suffering from the isolation.

Let’s support our medical professionals, who are selflessly putting their lives on the line. Let’s do what we can for those working on the medical front to put an end to this pandemic. Until then, let us be wise and remain hidden. May it be only for a brief moment.

Rabbi Yossi Marcus is the editor of commentaries on the Haggadah, Ethics of the Fathers, Megillat Esther, and Psalms. Together with wife Esty Marcus, he directs Chabad of the North Peninsula

This article was first published by the Jewish Journal.

The opinions and facts presented in this article are those of the author, and neither JNS nor its partners assume any responsibility for them.
You have read 3 articles this month.
Register to receive full access to JNS.

Just before you scroll on...

Israel is at war.

JNS is combating the stream of misinformation on Israel with real, honest and factual reporting. In order to deliver this in-depth, unbiased coverage of Israel and the Jewish world, we rely on readers like you.

The support you provide allows our journalists to deliver the truth, free from bias and hidden agendas. Can we count on your support?

Every contribution, big or small, helps JNS.org remain a trusted source of news you can rely on.

Become a part of our mission by donating today
Thank you. You are a loyal JNS Reader.
You have read more than 10 articles this month.
Please register for full access to continue reading and post comments.
Never miss a thing
Get the best stories faster with JNS breaking news updates